Sunday, December 11, 2011

Art Journal 12/1/11 - "Communist Utopia" by Thomas Hornung

What about this painting indicates Communism?
The setting is a decrepit, depressed gray landscape, an image often associated with the oppressive society Communism has been historically known to create. This gray monochrome is occasionally interrupted by patches of red - red being a color associated with Communism. Furthermore, there are eyes all over, watching the figure, which can be connected to the lack of privacy in most implemented Communistic societies.

What is the artist's view on Communism?
The artist views Communism as demoralizing and dehumanizing - the gray, broken landscape in the painting represents not only a horrible decay brought on by poor central management, but also the despair present in the mind of the person in the painting. The unsettling images of the eye give a clear negative impression while, more deeply, making a statement about the omnipresence of surveillance in a Communist society, as the painter sees it. Finally, notice that the figure is positioned in such a way that we can not see his face - the painter likely means to indicate to us that Communism erases individuality.

Explain the title.
The title is probably meant to be ironic, saying that with Communism this is the type of "utopia" we will get - one of decay and distrust. This usage of the title is a clear jab at those who would claim that Communism does create a utopia. Alternatively, the title could be an example of alternate truth - the title is true, but not in the way that we normally read it. In this case it may be true in the sense that this isn't a utopia brought about communism, but rather a utopia for communists - in this case, the painter would essentially be accusing Communist leaders of purposefully creating this sort of dystopic society.

Listening Journal 11/28/11 - "Don't You Want Me?" by The Human League

1. What is the subject matter?
The song depicts a couple, who have been together "for five years." It seems that the man somehow got the woman's career on track, as he says, "I picked you up, turned you around, out you back on your feet." The woman, however, believes hi role was exaggerated, saying, "But even then I knew I'd find a much better place/Either with or without you."

2. What is the difference between the 2 sides of the story?
The man believes the woman's success was due to him, saying he "turned [her] into something new." The woman disagrees, saying her success was inevitably going to occur before she met him.

3. With who do you side and why?
It's hard to say that I side with either of these characters, given the sparsity of detail that we have. The song doesn't provide detail enough to tell which character is right. If the man is right, the woman could be viewed as acting ungrateful and unjustly spurning her long-time lover. On the other hand, if the woman is right, the man comes off as conceited, controlling, and pathetic in his attempts to keep her with him. Ultimately our judgment of whether his pleas are justified (though admittedly his threat to "put her back" is disconcerting regardless of who's right) is impaired by our utter lack of real details on these two characters' history.

Monday, December 5, 2011

Final Brave New World Reading Journal

1. Does Aldous Huxley seem more to agree with Mustafa Mond or John the Savage, especially considering the ending of the book?

2. What, thematically, is Huxley trying to tell us with his persistent use of Shakespeare? What does "brave new world" ultimately mean?

3. How do the different objectives of the world governments in 1984 and Brave New World necessitate their different governing styles?