Sunday, April 15, 2012

Final Cuckoo's Nest Reading Blog

What is the meaning of the rhyme, "One flew east, one flew west, one flew over the cuckoo's nest?"
One conclusion can be made with near certainty: this symbol's meaning relies on the pun of the word "cuckoo," meaning both a type of bird and a synonym for insane. The questions remaining then are: who flew over the cuckoo's nest, and what about the "ones" who flew east and west?

Regarding who, only one character can really be a candidate, for only one character could possibly lend his title to this novel (more on that later): McMurphy. McMurphy flew "over the cuckoo's nest" in that he spent his time among these "crazy" people without himself being crazy; in other words, he was above, or "over," these "cuckoos."

What then is the rest of the rhyme for? One might just say that it completes some sort of reference Kesey was making to something he was familiar with, i.e. these words were included for pertinence' sake. However, in the realm of literary criticism, it often helps to make the (often baseless) assumption that all decisions are thought out. In this case, we might expect that the east and west do not represent particular characters or even classes so much as they represent McMurphy's habit of bucking society's norms. Rather than pick a direction - east or west - McMurphy picks his own option, an option that no other person might have taken: over the cuckoo's nest.

How effective is Kesey's choice of title?
The key to a good title, I perceive, is creating enough a mystique that never goes away, without allowing that mystique to pass into insanity. A writer might go to one of two extremes in choosing a bad name for a novel: McMurphy or The Insane Asylum would be far too straightforward: they tell us only easily-identifiable details of the novel. Inversely, Crocodiles in the Moonlight would have been utter nonsense - it means nothing. A great title creates a feeling of yearning to find out what it means - and after we understand this, we understand how profoundly it describes the novel. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, to Kesey's credit, is a perfect example of this: the rhyme never appears until the last pages of the book, and when it does we are still not able to put a definite meaning to it. But its placement in the novel is so momentous, so memorable, that the phrase seems a natural fit to describe the book in its entirety.

What significance did the two suicides - Cheswick's and Billy Bibbit's - each have for the story?
Cheswick's death can be viewed as a dynamic event for McMurphy. Prior to this point, McMurphy had realized what he had to lose and momentarily given up on his quest to undermine the Big Nurse. Cheswick's suicide emphasized the negative effects of this - McMurphy was forced to face the fact that he was now responsible for these people. Cheswick had killed himself because he felt all hope had been lost. McMurphy's return to his quest after Cheswick's death represents the shift of McMurphy accepting his responsibility, accepting the mantle of protector and savior for the patients.

Billy's death, though perhaps a bit late for this purpose, seems to serve to vilify the nurse more in our minds. Knowing what we do about Billy's problems of anxiety regarding his mother and knowing that the nurse is aware of these as well, we can not help but blame Nurse Ratched for Billy's death. Either the nurse callously ignored his safety, or she purposefully drove him to suicide as an example to the others. Nonetheless, being in the position of "angel of mercy" as Harding describes her, the Big Nurse has acted in direct contradiction to her obligations. We might ask why does Kesey choose to have such an important development moment occur so late in the novel? Perhaps to earn support for McMurphy, in light of what he does soon after: effectively rapes and assaults Nurse Ratched. This is behavior that most of us would deem highly unacceptable in most situations. But I myself found myself somewhat relieved that McMurphy did this. Perhaps Kesey anticipated this effect, anticipated that we would support McMurphy's outburst only if we felt the recipient truly deserved it.

Did Kesey's choice to kill McMurphy make the novel more effective?
Yes, for several reasons. The first is a sense of closure. We can't have McMurphy hanging around the hospital for the rest of his days, especially not in a vegetative state. This provides a nagging wonder in our brains, whatever happened to McMurphy? For Kesey's novel to have any finality, and therefore any effectiveness, McMurphy's story has to deliberately and decisively end.

Furthermore, we might consider the alternatives to McMurphy's death. As noted, living out the rest of his days in a hospital provides no closure. Nor do dismissal or escape provide much. Each of these also present further problems. Dismissal seems impossible unless McMurphy heels to Nurse Ratched, or else the Nurse is replaced. Obeying the Nurse would undo all of McMurphy's work, and at this point still would not probably earn his freedom. Replacing the Nurse might have been possible, but it is clear from the final presentation of Nurse Ratched that Kesey intends for us to see her as a broken shell of her former self. Ratched must stick around, to serve as an example. Escape's problem is equally psychological, though McMurphy seems able to acknowledge it himself by staying. Abandonment of the ward would be exactly that: abandonment, of all the people McMurphy had worked so hard to help. McMurphy staying, and ultimately dying, allows us the reassurance that he died a martyr, helping those he had committed to.

There is a final meaning which I identified, particular to the fact that Chief killed McMurphy. Throughout much of the latter half of the novel, McMurphy and Chief develop an increasingly close relationship. When Chief finally speaks to McMurphy for the first time, when he and McMurphy are sent to Disturbed together, when he finally speaks to the other ward patients on behalf of McMurphy; all of these instances serve to build a sort of mentee-mentor relationship between Chief and McMurphy. For Chief to kill McMurphy, for me at least, represents the passing of the torch: the torch of sanity, of self-dependence. We might further extrapolate that Chief taking this torch thus spreads the fire through the ward. In other words, McMurphy's death is an admittance that he is no longer needed, that the patients of the ward can finally take care of themselves.

Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Cuckoo's Nest Reading Blog #2

By the end of Part I of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, McMurphy finally seems to have gained the upper hand in his ongoing competition with Nurse Ratched for dominance of the ward. The key turning point in this conflict is McMurphy's attempt to lift the panel in the Game Room. Though he fails, the final words that he speaks as he leaves the room seem to resonate with the ward patients: "'But I tried though,' he says. 'Goddammit, I sure as hell did that much, now, didn't I?'" Perhaps this was the moment when the patients realized that even if rebellion against Nurse Ratched was as futile as they all insisted, it was still worthwhile - that even if they failed, at least they could say they tried, and didn't just give into the nurse's control with their tails between their legs. The next day's vote to change the schedule ends Part I on a note of victory for McMurphy - he has managed to convince all twenty Acutes to vote against Nurse Ratched.

One vote, however, did not come from the Acutes. The one stand-out of the Chronics, the one Chronic with the wherewithal to raise his hand in support of McMurphy, was none other than our narrator, Chief Bromden. In this section of the book, as McMurphy escalates his rivalry with Nurse Ratched, Bromden gradually reveals more and more parts of himself and his past. The most interesting of these revelations occur due to the threat that Bromden seems to perceive from McMurphy. Bromden, it seems, has "gotten lost in the fog" - a concept which he goes into much further depth than ever before. Bromden is so far gone in his hallucinations, so resigned to his insanity, that he almost seems to resent McMurphy's attempts to "pull people out of the fog." He views this both as mad and as disruptive. In defending his reactions to the world he has lived in for so many years, Bromden reveals to us the depth of his resignation. Similarly, we receive a greater eye into Bromden's psychosis - during one night, when he did not take his medicine, Bromden experiences a violent dream in which one of the other Chronics is strung up  and slaughtered by the "Combine". The eerie undertones aside - since this very same Chronic did in fact die in his sleep that night - this presumably psychotic dream reveals the true nature of Bromden's illness - full-blown paranoiac hallucination. One can only ponder what might have caused this illness, though we do know that Bromden's father had less-than-friendly relations with the government. Whatever the causes of Bromden's psychosis, it does create a rather nice opening for McMurphy - Bromden has a quite-literally pathological fear of organized authority. The conflict between this impulse and Bromden's desire to stay "in the fog" proves to be the primary driving force behind Bromden's place in the novel, and its results will determine whether he ultimately sides with McMurphy or Nurse Ratched.

At this point, Bromden's final decision is unclear, as is the resolution to McMurphy and Nurse Ratched's conflict. However, we might very well be able to tell at this point whom we hope will win this competition. As the pressure builds upon both characters, each reveals aspects of themselves not previously bared. McMurphy, faced with an uninspired and apathetic ward, moves past what we might have perceived previously as merely profit-driven motives. McMurphy's attempts, and ultimate success, to capture the hearts and minds of the Acutes sufficiently to induce them to vote in his favor seems to be more than just another in a line of efforts to get under the skin of Nurse Ratched. Rather, it seems a legitimate call for action, a cry for help perhaps, or a battle cry. Meanwhile, Nurse Ratched's kind and beneficent facade slowly peels away - her twitches at McMurphy's insolence, which Bromden notices, and her increasingly iron-fisted attempts to put down McMurphy's vote reveal the monster that dwells within her - the monster Bromden has perceived from the beginning. As our antihero becomes more heroic and our villain more villainous, the line between them becomes clearer. We now can see clearly where we stand, and it is with McMurphy.


Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Cuckoo's Nest Reading Blog #1

The pair of The Great Gatsby and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest was, I am now convinced, well selected. Both books have major similarities, beginning with our characters. In both books we have similar character occupying similar roles.

In the role of hero is, once again, our narrator - now the half-Indian schizophrenic psychiatric patient Chief Bromden, who feigns deafness and muteness in an attempt to be "cagey." Bromden, strikes, we will find, a nice moderate foil to our extreme protagonist, McMurphy. While both seem to be aware of Nurse Ratched's wicked ways, Bromden does not go out of his way to cause trouble as a way of expressing this. Bromden shares our values (or at least mine) in that he resents the despotic "world of precision efficiency and tidiness" (page 26) that Big Nurse strives for. Bromden ultimately gains the identification of an antihero because, in contrast to McMurphy, the way he acts on this shared value is for the most part not objectionable - he simply tries to make do. Bromden is difficult to classify as a hero, as Nick was, because he does not fit our traditional role for the hero - saving the day, acting as a force of powerful good. On the contrary, both characters act merely as standard-bearers of our own values in a strange world, while merely observing the real action taking place between characters that we do not find as morally attractive.

If Bromden is our (passive) hero, what is the clear protagonist, McMurphy? By identifying Bromden's values as heroic - namely, his resentment of Ratched's control - we concede that McMurphy too shares our values, for he is perhaps the only other character that we can be sure opposes Bug Nurse's regime. On the other hand, McMurphy's personality and stylings do not endear him to the the audience - he is, as he has identified himself repeatedly, a gambler - by occupation, he even seems to claim. What, then, do we make of a character who works towards our goals but acts in a repugnant manner? Why, this is one variation of the antihero. McMurphy is an even poorer fit for the "traditional" hero than Bromden - he acts almost entirely out of self-interest, rather than any innate moral superiority. McMurphy's very presence is a result of his greed and moral destitution - he admits he is "no loony, or never knew it if [he] was" (page 67) and that he is only in the Psychiatric Ward because "that's the way [he] planned it" (page 67) and he "needed some new suckers" (page 66). In no way does McMurphy constitute a moral rolemodel or even stand-in. But his place in the action of the story, firmly pitted against the villain, earns him recognition of a hero of sorts - i.e., an antihero.

Who is this villain whom McMurphy moves against? Clearly our ethical and moral disagreements with them go far beyond the disgust we feel at McMurphy's conduct. This person must work towards a goal entirely contrary to our values. If McMurphy is immoral but moves towards a goal we perceive as good (the liberation of the Psych Ward patients), his ideal match for a villain is someone who seems moral (at least superficially) but moves towards ends we disagree with. The best fit for this among the main characters is unquestionably the Big Nurse, Nurse Ratched. Ratched's facade of morality may not be enough to fool the audience - for it can not fool Bromden, and Bromden is the filter through which all appearances must pass on their way to our perception - but it does seem to have fooled the majority of the patients: "Miss Ratched is a veritable angel of mercy and why just everyone knows it" (page 55) explains Harding to McMurphy. But McMurphy is ultimately able to convince Harding to repudiate this position. Why? Because McMurphy perceives the true ends, as Bromden does, that Nurse Ratched is moving towards. She is, as McMurphy puts it, a "ball-cutter", bent on keeping the whole Ward under her thumb. So long as the reader values independence as much as McMurphy does, Nurse Ratched's goal is ignoble, perhaps more so because we perceive that none of her patients receive any actual help in their problems - the Chronics are a permanent reminder of the general failure of the Ward as an institute of healing. It is not believable to us as the audience that Ratched actually intends to help her patients - her singular perceptible goal is the annihilation of free will within the Psychiatric Ward. To a reader that values self-determination to the greatest feasible extent, this brands her as the villain.

Monday, March 5, 2012

Final Great Gatsby Reading Journal

What was the purpose of the single appearance of Daisy and Tom's daughter?
The fact that Pammy appears precisely once in the entire novel is itself telling. Clearly Pammy is neglected, and many readers may have even forgotten that she exists. Gatsby, as Nick observes, seems to have been entirely unconvinced that she ever did exist. This neglect might then be translated to a symbol - most likely a symbol for the love between Daisy and Tom. The fact that she is neglected is reflective of the relative neglect that that relationship has suffered - again, so much that Gatsby doubts its very existence. However, her singular appearance is enough to assure us that she still exists, and that Daisy also seems to have legitimate feelings of affection for her. This could foreshadow similar revelations about Daisy and Tom's relationship, that Daisy still holds feelings for Tom, however invisible and unbelievable. The fact that Tom is never present while Pammy is could indicate two things. It could (a) clue us in that Pammy is a sort of stand-in for Tom (in terms of Daisy's affection for her) or (b) be symbolic of Tom's particular neglect of the relationship (as he is actively and remorselessly cheating on his wife).

Why did Fitzgerald choose to have the "owl-eyed man" appear at Gatsby's funeral?
From the beginning Owl-eyes had been picked out as an unusual specimen among Gatsby's partygoers. One might be inclined to think of him as "the typical drunk," but in fact there were many drunks at Gatsby's parties. Only Owl-eyes acted the way he did - with wide-eyed (perhaps a clever pun on Fitzgerald's part) enthusiasm about Gatsby. While the other party-goers regarded Gatsby with suspicion, Owl-eyes viewed him with admiration. While the other guests attended only for the drink and dancing, Owl-eyes seemed to attend out of a real enthusiasm about Gatsby, a real belief that he was a man worth being around. Perhaps those eyes were able to penetrate further than most - able to see the man behind the myth, if only in a vague format. Probably Fitzgerald wanted this character to act as a contrast to the typical guests - by showing us an example of somebody who really sincerely cared about Gatsby, the other guests are more precisely identified as phonies and crooks, who attended only for what carnal satisfaction they could take from it.

Was Fitzgerald right in ultimately making Gatsby the "loser" of this story?
One's answer to this question will ultimately depend on how romantically one is willing to view love. The tempting answer is that Gatsby should have won, that in chapter 7 Daisy should have said finally and emphatically that she did not, nor never had loved Tom, and she and Gatsby should have run off to get married and lived their lives happily ever after. But this is the fairy-tale version, and in reality human emotion is more complicated. What existed between Gatsby and Daisy five years prior can not be recovered in its entirety because the conditions can not be replicated. Even though Gatsby had made minor successes - having an affair, getting Daisy to say she loved him - he could not reach the peak they had experience five years before. That spark had been diluted, and nothing could truly rekindle it. In the end, Gatsby had to be the loser of this story. Did he deserve it? Certainly not. But it had to be so, for his cause was hopeless.


How effective was the symbolism of the “green light”?
By the ending pages of the novel it becomes fairly obvious what the green light was meant to represent – the unreasonable hope Gatsby held for his relationship with Daisy. It was that that he reached out to every night, reaching out to the love he sought to regain. It was that light that, as Nick perceived, lost its charm to Gatsby when Daisy was in his arms, as the realization slowly set in, however much he failed to admit it, that Daisy was not as he had built her up in his mind. But the symbol is not maintained well throughout much of the novel, when it very well could have been used again and again for these purposes. Furthermore, we were warned to look for meanings to the color green being used. But, unless we want to use some “universal” meaning for green, like nature or money or “go,” none of which make a terrible amount of sense, we have to go on pretenses built by other uses of green in the novel. Only two can be found. The first is the color that a bystander at first mistakenly thinks Gatsby's car is. This could be read into with questionable veracity. The only other use is more useful still – in the final pages, Nick alludes to how the “green landmass” of Manhattan must have acted as a symbol of hope for its Dutch discoverers – but comes so late as to come off almost as if it was shoved in to give quick explanation to the color. In short, Fitzgerald makes weak use of a strong symbol.

Monday, February 27, 2012

Great Gatsby Reading Blog #2

1.) What is the purpose of Meyer Wolfsheim as a character? How does he affect the way we see Gatsby?
Meyer Wolfsheim is the first clear hint the author gives us that Gatsby did not obtain his fortune by ordinary means. Already at this point our confidence in Gatsby's moral character should be shaken by the obvious fabrications within his story of his background, as recounted to Nick in the car on the way to New York. Wolfsheim confirms our suspicions, treating us to an example of the sort of people Gatsby likely had to collude with in order to gain his fortune. This sullies our perception of Gatsby and further brings him down to a human level.

2.) What does the backstory about Jay and Daisy's past do to our impressions of Gatsby?
While Meyer Wolfsheim serves to shame Gatsby in our eyes, learning about the latter's history with Daisy serves to make him a more tragically sympathetic character. What is not stated, but what we are meant to infer from the details of their history and from Gatsby's actions after we learn this, is that Gatsby was heartbroken when his relationship with Daisy broke off. Gatsby may be shady or suspect, but the facts of his past with Daisy cause him to become immediately more sympathetic. It is hard, after all, to hate the heartbroken.

3.) What does the story of the rest of Gatsby past due to our impressions of him?
The rest of Gatsby's story fills out the sketch of Gatsby's goals that we'd already received with the information about Daisy. We know that Gatsby has a short term goal of winning back Daisy. This fuller origin story then illuminates what his long term goal is and always has been - to reinvent himself as a classy and suave rich man. To become Jay Gatsby in his entirety, and to forever shed James Gatz. We can now sympathize with Gatsby not only on the grounds that he has been heartbroken, but on the grounds that in a very symbolic sense he represents the American dream - that axiomatic aspiration that any man can become a member of the elite.

4.) How does your overall impression of Gatsby change over these three chapters - do you like him more, less, and why?
This chapter did much to endear Jay Gatsby to me as a character. In the first three chapters, Gatsby is a distant but somewhat fascinating rich man. We know there is some great mystery behind him, but not whether it would mark him as a hero or villain. In these three chapters, those mysteries are revealed to us, and we find Gatsby at least leaning toward the side of hero, though perhaps more accurately described as an antihero. Gatsby, we find, was once and to a degree still is a very average human being. He is not truly a member of the elite, but a low-class drifter who has tried with all his heart to plant himself into the elite, and now that he is there seeks the only thing he could never manage to take for himself - his true love. In understanding Gatsby's motives, even if we may disagree with his actions taken to some degree, as in his probably shady dealings with characters such as Meyer Wolfsheim, we come to appreciate him more as a real human being, and thus to like him more. It is a strong belief of mine that it becomes harder to hate a person the more you understand them. Gatsby proves a brilliant example of this.

Sunday, February 26, 2012

Listening Journal 2/22/12 - "Black Bottom Stomp" by Jelly Roll Morton

How do you envision this music playing a part of Gatsby's parties?
Gatsby's parties are described, as best as I can tell, as having a constant font of music in the form of a band playing on some sort of stage in the garden. This song is exactly the sort I could picture as being part of that persistent background noise. There seems to be little time structure to Gatsby's parties, thus it might be presumed that any activity could be taking place at any moment. Some people may be dancing while this song plays, others gossiping about Gatsby's supposed shady origins, others simply getting completely and unabashedly intoxicated. This music provides the perfect setting for all the activities that might be going on at such an affair.

What is the mood? How/why?
The song is markedly upbeat in mood, carefree, perhaps ecstatic. The constant fast tempo and high-pitched horns do the best job of maintaining this mood. However, I feel that the occasional solos do much to establish a carefree mood, as if this is all in lighthearted fun.

What activities go along with this music?
Fast and energetic dancing, drinking, and socializing all seem to be the sorts of activities that would go well with this in the background.

Monday, February 20, 2012

Art Journal 2/16/12 - Justin Bua

At base we can say that Bua's style is abstract. It repeatedly utilizes distortions of space, color, and lines. Bua makes very noticeable usage of space, with a continuous flow between the fore-, mid-, and background. Objects in the background are warped in such a way as to look large and looming. Bua makes frequent use of curves in many places where they would not appear naturally. He also makes strong use of shadow. It may also be worth noting that Bua's favored subject is black culture.

Great Gatsby Reading Blog #1

Our clear hero is, conveniently, also our protagonist, Nick Carraway. Nick, more than any other character, shares my values as a reader. He reveals himself to be an honest and non-judgemental character. "I'm inclined to reserve all judgements," (page 1) Nick says, and "Every one suspects himself of at least one of the cardinal virtues, and this is mine: I am one of the few honest people that I have ever known" (page 60). This second quote, it should be noted, also seems to denote a pinch of modesty to Nick - he says that he "suspects" himself of this virtue, rather than taking it as granted fact. Ultimately, a hero should be a reflection of the audience, and Nick serves well in this role. He is the only character with any detectable degree of normality, of not being part of this strange, foreign, exotic world of Prohibition-era parties. We may expect Nick to soon shed his complete neutrality on most matters and perhaps become more of a force for good in the story.

If the hero is what the audience is, the antihero is perhaps best viewed as what the audience would be with no restrictions placed on them. An antihero may share the motivations and overall morals of the audience, but does not share the actual constraints, either societal or otherwise, normally placed on the audience. In this sense, Jay Gatsby is a fine example of an antihero. Gatsby's morals and cadence, it would seem, are more or less aligned with the audience's: "He smiled understandingly - much more than understandingly" (page 48). This whole paragraph is meant to communicate that Gatsby is in fact a very down-to-earth, friendly person. At the same time, though, we must take into account his wider actions - mainly the wild and raucous parties he throws each night. The parties rather contradict what most people would consider acceptable behavior. But though the action itself contradicts the audience's values, the desires bearing it are very much the readers' as well: to have fun. We should also consider that Gatsby does not seem altogether hedonistic at his parties. Nick observes that he does not drink at his parties, and Gatsby's remark, "I'm afraid I'm not a very good host" (page 48) indicates that he means for others to have fun as well. Within the rest of the book, I expect we will see further shady activities from the not-so-shady-himself Jay Gatsby.

The villain, then, is quite simply defined as the character who does things we consider wrong, and for the wrong reasons. The prime example in The Great Gatsby (though there are many) would be Tom Buchanan. Tom hardly makes a good impression when he starts on about "The Rise of the Colored Empires" (page 13), which immediately pegs him as a racist. Our opinion of Tom only sinks when we find out that "Tom's got some woman in New York" (page 15). Tom is cheating on Daisy, a character that so far we have had no reason to wish such a thing on. Tom finally solidifies his role as a hard-boiled villain when it is revealed that he has told people he can not divorce Daisy because she is Catholic and does not believe in divorce, when in fact "Daisy was not a Catholic, and [Nick] was a little shocked at the elaborateness of the lie" (page 34). This exempts Tom from any chance he had at redemption. Plainly he can not bring himself even to break it off with Daisy, likely because he knows she has done nothing to deserve what he has done to her, and thus he would come out of the divorce looking like what he is - a villain. One might expect Tom to further take on his role as the scum of the earth, and perhaps even offer some opposition to Nick or Gatsby (or both).

Sunday, January 29, 2012

50 POSTS!!!!

I can't believe we made it to this wonderful milestone. I'd like to thank all four of my loyal followers: Mr. Behler for grading these 50 posts silently and diligently, my friends Bay and Sarah for always supporting me, and Ms. Koutsounis for continuing to show her loyalty despite not having taught this class for about two months. I'd also like to thank the Academy and all my other wonderful teachers, as well as my parents for raising me so well. I couldn't have done this without all of you.

Mencken vs. Kroll: Who Was More Persuasive?

In making this comparison we are given a relatively simple task - both of these authors rely on a core pathos appeal to make their argument. Neither author tries to argue that the death penalty deters criminals, that it reduces crime rates, etc. Similarly, neither spends much time, if any, appealing to their own credibility or anybody else's who may have a say on the issue. Each author's argument essentially centers on one idea - how the death penalty emotionally affects those involved. The question then becomes: Who creates a more emotionally appealing argument, Mencken or Kroll? In answering this there is no doubt: Kroll creates the more appealing piece. From the beginning Mencken comes off as unsympathetic - he is dismissive and arrogant, and makes no attempt to apologize for it. In contrast, Kroll's piece tactfully gathers sympathy in part by declining to comment on the innocence or guilt, the right or wrong of his friend. Kroll's piece is emotion at its best. Even the most impartial of readers will find it hard to ignore the pain and horror Kroll experiences. Mencken's piece, by contrast, is emotion at its worst. Mencken focuses not on sympathetic and genuine emotion but on a cold argument that appeals to the emotions we all would prefer not to give into. Comparing these two essays is a bit like comparing Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X. One focused on positive emotions like hope and love and inspired sympathy in his audience. The other focused on negatives like revenge and anger, and inspired fear even from those who agreed with him. Which of these figures is remembered more fondly? Mr. King of course. History and literature both show that appeals to positive pathos rather consistently beat out appeals to negative.

Listening Journal 1/25/12 - "Sixteen Military Wives" by The Decemberists

What is this song about?
The song is about people becoming numbers; numbers are repeated throughout the song - "sixteen military wives," "fifteen celebrity minds," "fourteen cannibal kings." The chorus describes the way in which society allows this to go on entirely under its nose and, in fact, seems to approve of it.

What is the theme of this song?
It seems to me that that this song wants us to think about indifference and willful ignorance, perhaps the adage "ignorance is bliss." The happy pace and melody of the song is explained well when we think about "the anchorman on TV" who goes "Ladedadeda." The song asks us to think about how the lyrics affect us when we look at their details. Sixteen military wives inspire indifference. It's just a number after all, and this allows us, along with the upbeat music, to listen to the song as something happy on a shallow level. But what about when we look at the details? "Seventeen company men/Out of which only  twelve will make it back again." There are painful truths behind these numbers, and we have to reconsider whether we are being indifferent to the details behind these numbers.

Listening Journal 1/23/12 - "Race for the Prize" by The Flaming Lips

The song appears to me to want the listener to think about the lengths people will go to for success, and the motivations behind them. In listening to the song, there is a definite "soaring" feel to the composition. The tones are high and have a relatively upbeat wind through the song. But on so many occasions, as we enter the chorus, the breeze stops. It's noticeable to the listener, almost lamentable, as if the kind summer breeze had suddenly dropped away. We're left to wonder where it went - several times in fact - and this bittersweet ride is what helps us to understand our theme. The lyrics further reflect this bittersweet attitude: the scientists are "racing for the good of all mankind," a noble cause to be sure. But the lyrics characterize doubt in this same nobility: "But it's so dangerous/But they're determined." The chorus, accompanied by the aforementioned musical nadir, clears up our theme considerably: "Theirs is to win/If it kills them." Our enjoyment of the upward climb to success is interrupted by this bitter twinge of reality and doubt. How far must humans be willing to go to achieve their dreams?

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

JFK Inauguration Speech Fallacy

1. Write a quote from the speech that commits a fallacy.
"If a free society cannot help the many who are poor, it cannot save the few who are rich."


2. Tell what fallacy it commits and explain why it is guilty of committing that logical flaw.
This is a non sequitur. Whether or not we can feed the poor has no logical connection to whether or not we can "save the rich." Therefore, because JFK has established no logical flow between his premise and his conclusion, he commits non sequitur.


3. Explain why a speech that blatantly commits so many fallacies can still be so effective and so famous.
Substance, as important as it is, is not in itself memorable. Rhetoric is memorable. To this end, one can dress up the most fallacious of arguments and make it sound convincing. The Kennedy speech is a brilliant example of this, for when we look below the surface of his words we see that not only are numerous fallacies committed, but that he is hardly arguing for anything. Kennedy demonstrates a brilliant ability to dress up the most hollow of ideas in bombast. This rhetorical mastery is what sticks in the public mind, and this is why speeches like Kennedy's remain so famous to this day.

Monday, January 16, 2012

1/12/12 - "Duck and Cover"

Overt message?
"Duck and cover" - it's repeated multiple times, the video is even named for this idea.

Covert message?
The American government will protect us from harm. Civil defense works and "older people" are shown to be those best trusted. As a whole, the "duck and cover" concept is not really about safety - an atomic bomb blast would probably kill you anyway - but about the illusion of safety and the government being the primary providers of it.

Propaganda or information? Why?
Ducking and covering will not protect anyone from an atomic bomb. The government at the time knew the power of the atomic bomb. The purpose of this video is not to inform, but to provide an illusory idea of possible safety in the face of the nuclear threat, and presents the government as the only body capable of protecting us from this threat. In this way, "Duck and Cover" is clearly propaganda.

1/11/12 - "Destination: Earth"

Overt message?
Oil and competition allow for a better society.

Covert message?
Oil companies should not be questioned because they produce benefits for all.

Why is it propaganda? Specific techniques?
The film is essentially making assertions based on "American values" to convince the viewer that oil companies work for the common man. Never is this stated outright, but the ideas of oil and competition are treated with reverence to butter the audience up for this idea. The film continually uses glittering generalities, characterizing the oil industry as contributing to "freedom" and "standard of living" and "security."

Sunday, January 8, 2012

Propaganda (WWII 1941-1945) - 1/5/12

What is the overt message?
The poster implores the viewer to eat less bread tin order to support the war effort.

What is the covert message?
The covert message seems to affirm a woman's "place" in society - the kitchen, which this poster claims is the key to victory. Notice instead of opting for a non-occupied or co-gender image, the poster utilizes the image of a woman cooking, thus indicating that specifically women are expected to "help their country" by working in the kitchen.

How does the disparity in the two of these make it propaganda?
The poster conceals itself as informative - the kitchen is the key to victory. Eating less bread is simply framed as a recommendation based on these "facts." In reality, the fact is presented in such a way to convince the audience of something that is not being stated directly, in this case that women ought to help their country by spending their efforts in the kitchen.

Listening Journal 1/4/12 - "Clampdown" by The Clash

1. What is the song about? How do you know?
The song is about authority, specifically giving in to authority. We can see this in the continual repetition of the phrase "working for the clampdown." While the "clampdown" is never explicitly definied, it seems to be the manifestation of authority and society "clamping down" on one's individuality. As the song says, "No man born with a living soul/Can be working for the clampdown." Thus it seems that in some way the clampdown destroys individuality or the living soul."

2. What musical elements add to your lyrical interpretation?
Musical elements of songs often represent the opinion of the artist towards the topic of the lyrics. Combining this with an understanding of who the artist is can give a better understanding of what exactly the lyrics are discussing. The Clash are often viewed as one of the pioneering bands of the punk tradition that began in the 70s and 80s. This punk culture put strong emphasis on resistance of authority. Now, combine this with the musical elements. The chorus line repeated throughout the song, "working for the clampdown," seems almost as though it is a repeated resistance against something, then forced back down. However it keeps coming back. Other elements like this can be found in the short riff that occurs at the end of several lines and the cymbal strikes that interrupt the otherwise steady beat of the song. All in all, the music of this song serves to confirm that the song deals with rebellion against something - based on The Clash's background, almost certainly authority.

3. What in the song relates to propaganda/rhetoric/persuasion/argument?
Overt propaganda references are made in the first verse, which seems to make allusions to Nazi propaganda. References to posters, an easily recognized form of propaganda, are used. As a whole, however, the ambiguous "you" in the lyrics seems to have become a victim of propaganda, slowly and covertly converted to "working for the clampdown," until eventually he has "someone to boss around/Make ya feel big now."

Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Propaganda, Persuasion, Rhetoric, and Argument (G, H, I)

Four Quotes: #373, 392, 435, 499

Of all these quotes, one that stood out particularly well to me was #499, which follows:  "The
biggest danger I encountered in my years as an editor was a reflective cynicism among some
reporters that led them to assume they knew what a story was about, before they had actually done
the reporting. They would begin with an assumption of who the good guys and the bad guys were,
and then organize the facts around that hypothesis. Sometimes, reporters were so confident about
their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to
contact the 'bad guys.'" --David Ignatius


The phenomenon that Ignatius describes is most commonly referred to as confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is the natural tendency of the incautious mind to seek out only details which confirm its previously formed opinions, or else to interpret new information consistently in a way that supports those opinions. Confirmation bias is common to most people. Even the most discerning sketpics commit it from time to time without realizing it. Journalists, then, are no exception. They are subject to the same faults as most human beings, even if we would prefer them not to be.

What comes of a journalist's confirmation bias is something different however. A journalist is in a unique position to affect the views of large groups of people - depending on readership, perhaps millions of people. As a result, what may be an unintentional act of confirmation bias can soon become indistinguishable from rhetoric and propaganda.

As Mr. Ignatius notes, reporters often have a preconceived notion of a story's "good guys" and "bad guys." They would thus be expected to reflect this in their language and description of the story. Confirmation bias then translates into something closely resembling rhetorical language. In a story about the debt crisis, a liberal reporter may describe the Republicans as "stubbornly resisting compromise" and the Democrats as "persistent." While this might be purposeful, the journalist may as easily be given the benefit of the doubt as simply subconsciously biased. He/she thus uses words in a way that reflects his/her own viewpoint on the issue, and thus acts to persuade the audience in his/her favor, all without being conscious that this is what he/she is doing.

Furthermore, this confirmation bias may go as far as a withholding of information. Mr. Ignatius observes that "Sometimes, reporters were so confident about their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to contact the 'bad guys.'" Withholding of information can come in two flavors. Misinformation, or accidental withholding, occurs when the informing party is aware the withheld information exists. If a friend tells me we have an eight page essay due tomorrow, and doesn't know that it's actually supposed to be triple-spaced, I have been misinformed. Disinformation, however, occurs when the informing party knows they are withholding information, and does so for a purpose. If my friend told me about the eight page essay, but not the triple-spacing, because she was pulling an incredibly cruel prank on me, that would be disinformation. The two are often difficult to discern. Are the numerous reporting flaws on Fox News that have been pointed out over the years innocent misinformation or calculated disinformation? More importantly, does it matter? While our working definition of propaganda should imply that it is purposeful, does intent make a difference? A reporter may innocently forget to contact a "bad guy" due to confirmation bias, but are the effects different than if  he had omitted that party's opinion to push a point of view? In either case, the audience is told something that may not fully represent the truth, and thus is likely to believe what the author believes. Confirmation bias then, while not entirely the same as propaganda, can produce nearly identical results.