Showing posts with label persuasion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label persuasion. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

JFK Inauguration Speech Fallacy

1. Write a quote from the speech that commits a fallacy.
"If a free society cannot help the many who are poor, it cannot save the few who are rich."


2. Tell what fallacy it commits and explain why it is guilty of committing that logical flaw.
This is a non sequitur. Whether or not we can feed the poor has no logical connection to whether or not we can "save the rich." Therefore, because JFK has established no logical flow between his premise and his conclusion, he commits non sequitur.


3. Explain why a speech that blatantly commits so many fallacies can still be so effective and so famous.
Substance, as important as it is, is not in itself memorable. Rhetoric is memorable. To this end, one can dress up the most fallacious of arguments and make it sound convincing. The Kennedy speech is a brilliant example of this, for when we look below the surface of his words we see that not only are numerous fallacies committed, but that he is hardly arguing for anything. Kennedy demonstrates a brilliant ability to dress up the most hollow of ideas in bombast. This rhetorical mastery is what sticks in the public mind, and this is why speeches like Kennedy's remain so famous to this day.

Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Propaganda, Persuasion, Rhetoric, and Argument (G, H, I)

Four Quotes: #373, 392, 435, 499

Of all these quotes, one that stood out particularly well to me was #499, which follows:  "The
biggest danger I encountered in my years as an editor was a reflective cynicism among some
reporters that led them to assume they knew what a story was about, before they had actually done
the reporting. They would begin with an assumption of who the good guys and the bad guys were,
and then organize the facts around that hypothesis. Sometimes, reporters were so confident about
their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to
contact the 'bad guys.'" --David Ignatius


The phenomenon that Ignatius describes is most commonly referred to as confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is the natural tendency of the incautious mind to seek out only details which confirm its previously formed opinions, or else to interpret new information consistently in a way that supports those opinions. Confirmation bias is common to most people. Even the most discerning sketpics commit it from time to time without realizing it. Journalists, then, are no exception. They are subject to the same faults as most human beings, even if we would prefer them not to be.

What comes of a journalist's confirmation bias is something different however. A journalist is in a unique position to affect the views of large groups of people - depending on readership, perhaps millions of people. As a result, what may be an unintentional act of confirmation bias can soon become indistinguishable from rhetoric and propaganda.

As Mr. Ignatius notes, reporters often have a preconceived notion of a story's "good guys" and "bad guys." They would thus be expected to reflect this in their language and description of the story. Confirmation bias then translates into something closely resembling rhetorical language. In a story about the debt crisis, a liberal reporter may describe the Republicans as "stubbornly resisting compromise" and the Democrats as "persistent." While this might be purposeful, the journalist may as easily be given the benefit of the doubt as simply subconsciously biased. He/she thus uses words in a way that reflects his/her own viewpoint on the issue, and thus acts to persuade the audience in his/her favor, all without being conscious that this is what he/she is doing.

Furthermore, this confirmation bias may go as far as a withholding of information. Mr. Ignatius observes that "Sometimes, reporters were so confident about their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to contact the 'bad guys.'" Withholding of information can come in two flavors. Misinformation, or accidental withholding, occurs when the informing party is aware the withheld information exists. If a friend tells me we have an eight page essay due tomorrow, and doesn't know that it's actually supposed to be triple-spaced, I have been misinformed. Disinformation, however, occurs when the informing party knows they are withholding information, and does so for a purpose. If my friend told me about the eight page essay, but not the triple-spacing, because she was pulling an incredibly cruel prank on me, that would be disinformation. The two are often difficult to discern. Are the numerous reporting flaws on Fox News that have been pointed out over the years innocent misinformation or calculated disinformation? More importantly, does it matter? While our working definition of propaganda should imply that it is purposeful, does intent make a difference? A reporter may innocently forget to contact a "bad guy" due to confirmation bias, but are the effects different than if  he had omitted that party's opinion to push a point of view? In either case, the audience is told something that may not fully represent the truth, and thus is likely to believe what the author believes. Confirmation bias then, while not entirely the same as propaganda, can produce nearly identical results.