What is the meaning of the rhyme, "One flew east, one flew west, one flew over the cuckoo's nest?"
One conclusion can be made with near certainty: this symbol's meaning relies on the pun of the word "cuckoo," meaning both a type of bird and a synonym for insane. The questions remaining then are: who flew over the cuckoo's nest, and what about the "ones" who flew east and west?
Regarding who, only one character can really be a candidate, for only one character could possibly lend his title to this novel (more on that later): McMurphy. McMurphy flew "over the cuckoo's nest" in that he spent his time among these "crazy" people without himself being crazy; in other words, he was above, or "over," these "cuckoos."
What then is the rest of the rhyme for? One might just say that it completes some sort of reference Kesey was making to something he was familiar with, i.e. these words were included for pertinence' sake. However, in the realm of literary criticism, it often helps to make the (often baseless) assumption that all decisions are thought out. In this case, we might expect that the east and west do not represent particular characters or even classes so much as they represent McMurphy's habit of bucking society's norms. Rather than pick a direction - east or west - McMurphy picks his own option, an option that no other person might have taken: over the cuckoo's nest.
How effective is Kesey's choice of title?
The key to a good title, I perceive, is creating enough a mystique that never goes away, without allowing that mystique to pass into insanity. A writer might go to one of two extremes in choosing a bad name for a novel: McMurphy or The Insane Asylum would be far too straightforward: they tell us only easily-identifiable details of the novel. Inversely, Crocodiles in the Moonlight would have been utter nonsense - it means nothing. A great title creates a feeling of yearning to find out what it means - and after we understand this, we understand how profoundly it describes the novel. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, to Kesey's credit, is a perfect example of this: the rhyme never appears until the last pages of the book, and when it does we are still not able to put a definite meaning to it. But its placement in the novel is so momentous, so memorable, that the phrase seems a natural fit to describe the book in its entirety.
What significance did the two suicides - Cheswick's and Billy Bibbit's - each have for the story?
Cheswick's death can be viewed as a dynamic event for McMurphy. Prior to this point, McMurphy had realized what he had to lose and momentarily given up on his quest to undermine the Big Nurse. Cheswick's suicide emphasized the negative effects of this - McMurphy was forced to face the fact that he was now responsible for these people. Cheswick had killed himself because he felt all hope had been lost. McMurphy's return to his quest after Cheswick's death represents the shift of McMurphy accepting his responsibility, accepting the mantle of protector and savior for the patients.
Billy's death, though perhaps a bit late for this purpose, seems to serve to vilify the nurse more in our minds. Knowing what we do about Billy's problems of anxiety regarding his mother and knowing that the nurse is aware of these as well, we can not help but blame Nurse Ratched for Billy's death. Either the nurse callously ignored his safety, or she purposefully drove him to suicide as an example to the others. Nonetheless, being in the position of "angel of mercy" as Harding describes her, the Big Nurse has acted in direct contradiction to her obligations. We might ask why does Kesey choose to have such an important development moment occur so late in the novel? Perhaps to earn support for McMurphy, in light of what he does soon after: effectively rapes and assaults Nurse Ratched. This is behavior that most of us would deem highly unacceptable in most situations. But I myself found myself somewhat relieved that McMurphy did this. Perhaps Kesey anticipated this effect, anticipated that we would support McMurphy's outburst only if we felt the recipient truly deserved it.
Did Kesey's choice to kill McMurphy make the novel more effective?
Yes, for several reasons. The first is a sense of closure. We can't have McMurphy hanging around the hospital for the rest of his days, especially not in a vegetative state. This provides a nagging wonder in our brains, whatever happened to McMurphy? For Kesey's novel to have any finality, and therefore any effectiveness, McMurphy's story has to deliberately and decisively end.
Furthermore, we might consider the alternatives to McMurphy's death. As noted, living out the rest of his days in a hospital provides no closure. Nor do dismissal or escape provide much. Each of these also present further problems. Dismissal seems impossible unless McMurphy heels to Nurse Ratched, or else the Nurse is replaced. Obeying the Nurse would undo all of McMurphy's work, and at this point still would not probably earn his freedom. Replacing the Nurse might have been possible, but it is clear from the final presentation of Nurse Ratched that Kesey intends for us to see her as a broken shell of her former self. Ratched must stick around, to serve as an example. Escape's problem is equally psychological, though McMurphy seems able to acknowledge it himself by staying. Abandonment of the ward would be exactly that: abandonment, of all the people McMurphy had worked so hard to help. McMurphy staying, and ultimately dying, allows us the reassurance that he died a martyr, helping those he had committed to.
There is a final meaning which I identified, particular to the fact that Chief killed McMurphy. Throughout much of the latter half of the novel, McMurphy and Chief develop an increasingly close relationship. When Chief finally speaks to McMurphy for the first time, when he and McMurphy are sent to Disturbed together, when he finally speaks to the other ward patients on behalf of McMurphy; all of these instances serve to build a sort of mentee-mentor relationship between Chief and McMurphy. For Chief to kill McMurphy, for me at least, represents the passing of the torch: the torch of sanity, of self-dependence. We might further extrapolate that Chief taking this torch thus spreads the fire through the ward. In other words, McMurphy's death is an admittance that he is no longer needed, that the patients of the ward can finally take care of themselves.
No comments:
Post a Comment