Showing posts with label appeals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label appeals. Show all posts

Sunday, January 29, 2012

Mencken vs. Kroll: Who Was More Persuasive?

In making this comparison we are given a relatively simple task - both of these authors rely on a core pathos appeal to make their argument. Neither author tries to argue that the death penalty deters criminals, that it reduces crime rates, etc. Similarly, neither spends much time, if any, appealing to their own credibility or anybody else's who may have a say on the issue. Each author's argument essentially centers on one idea - how the death penalty emotionally affects those involved. The question then becomes: Who creates a more emotionally appealing argument, Mencken or Kroll? In answering this there is no doubt: Kroll creates the more appealing piece. From the beginning Mencken comes off as unsympathetic - he is dismissive and arrogant, and makes no attempt to apologize for it. In contrast, Kroll's piece tactfully gathers sympathy in part by declining to comment on the innocence or guilt, the right or wrong of his friend. Kroll's piece is emotion at its best. Even the most impartial of readers will find it hard to ignore the pain and horror Kroll experiences. Mencken's piece, by contrast, is emotion at its worst. Mencken focuses not on sympathetic and genuine emotion but on a cold argument that appeals to the emotions we all would prefer not to give into. Comparing these two essays is a bit like comparing Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X. One focused on positive emotions like hope and love and inspired sympathy in his audience. The other focused on negatives like revenge and anger, and inspired fear even from those who agreed with him. Which of these figures is remembered more fondly? Mr. King of course. History and literature both show that appeals to positive pathos rather consistently beat out appeals to negative.