Showing posts with label antihero. Show all posts
Showing posts with label antihero. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Cuckoo's Nest Reading Blog #1

The pair of The Great Gatsby and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest was, I am now convinced, well selected. Both books have major similarities, beginning with our characters. In both books we have similar character occupying similar roles.

In the role of hero is, once again, our narrator - now the half-Indian schizophrenic psychiatric patient Chief Bromden, who feigns deafness and muteness in an attempt to be "cagey." Bromden, strikes, we will find, a nice moderate foil to our extreme protagonist, McMurphy. While both seem to be aware of Nurse Ratched's wicked ways, Bromden does not go out of his way to cause trouble as a way of expressing this. Bromden shares our values (or at least mine) in that he resents the despotic "world of precision efficiency and tidiness" (page 26) that Big Nurse strives for. Bromden ultimately gains the identification of an antihero because, in contrast to McMurphy, the way he acts on this shared value is for the most part not objectionable - he simply tries to make do. Bromden is difficult to classify as a hero, as Nick was, because he does not fit our traditional role for the hero - saving the day, acting as a force of powerful good. On the contrary, both characters act merely as standard-bearers of our own values in a strange world, while merely observing the real action taking place between characters that we do not find as morally attractive.

If Bromden is our (passive) hero, what is the clear protagonist, McMurphy? By identifying Bromden's values as heroic - namely, his resentment of Ratched's control - we concede that McMurphy too shares our values, for he is perhaps the only other character that we can be sure opposes Bug Nurse's regime. On the other hand, McMurphy's personality and stylings do not endear him to the the audience - he is, as he has identified himself repeatedly, a gambler - by occupation, he even seems to claim. What, then, do we make of a character who works towards our goals but acts in a repugnant manner? Why, this is one variation of the antihero. McMurphy is an even poorer fit for the "traditional" hero than Bromden - he acts almost entirely out of self-interest, rather than any innate moral superiority. McMurphy's very presence is a result of his greed and moral destitution - he admits he is "no loony, or never knew it if [he] was" (page 67) and that he is only in the Psychiatric Ward because "that's the way [he] planned it" (page 67) and he "needed some new suckers" (page 66). In no way does McMurphy constitute a moral rolemodel or even stand-in. But his place in the action of the story, firmly pitted against the villain, earns him recognition of a hero of sorts - i.e., an antihero.

Who is this villain whom McMurphy moves against? Clearly our ethical and moral disagreements with them go far beyond the disgust we feel at McMurphy's conduct. This person must work towards a goal entirely contrary to our values. If McMurphy is immoral but moves towards a goal we perceive as good (the liberation of the Psych Ward patients), his ideal match for a villain is someone who seems moral (at least superficially) but moves towards ends we disagree with. The best fit for this among the main characters is unquestionably the Big Nurse, Nurse Ratched. Ratched's facade of morality may not be enough to fool the audience - for it can not fool Bromden, and Bromden is the filter through which all appearances must pass on their way to our perception - but it does seem to have fooled the majority of the patients: "Miss Ratched is a veritable angel of mercy and why just everyone knows it" (page 55) explains Harding to McMurphy. But McMurphy is ultimately able to convince Harding to repudiate this position. Why? Because McMurphy perceives the true ends, as Bromden does, that Nurse Ratched is moving towards. She is, as McMurphy puts it, a "ball-cutter", bent on keeping the whole Ward under her thumb. So long as the reader values independence as much as McMurphy does, Nurse Ratched's goal is ignoble, perhaps more so because we perceive that none of her patients receive any actual help in their problems - the Chronics are a permanent reminder of the general failure of the Ward as an institute of healing. It is not believable to us as the audience that Ratched actually intends to help her patients - her singular perceptible goal is the annihilation of free will within the Psychiatric Ward. To a reader that values self-determination to the greatest feasible extent, this brands her as the villain.

Monday, February 20, 2012

Great Gatsby Reading Blog #1

Our clear hero is, conveniently, also our protagonist, Nick Carraway. Nick, more than any other character, shares my values as a reader. He reveals himself to be an honest and non-judgemental character. "I'm inclined to reserve all judgements," (page 1) Nick says, and "Every one suspects himself of at least one of the cardinal virtues, and this is mine: I am one of the few honest people that I have ever known" (page 60). This second quote, it should be noted, also seems to denote a pinch of modesty to Nick - he says that he "suspects" himself of this virtue, rather than taking it as granted fact. Ultimately, a hero should be a reflection of the audience, and Nick serves well in this role. He is the only character with any detectable degree of normality, of not being part of this strange, foreign, exotic world of Prohibition-era parties. We may expect Nick to soon shed his complete neutrality on most matters and perhaps become more of a force for good in the story.

If the hero is what the audience is, the antihero is perhaps best viewed as what the audience would be with no restrictions placed on them. An antihero may share the motivations and overall morals of the audience, but does not share the actual constraints, either societal or otherwise, normally placed on the audience. In this sense, Jay Gatsby is a fine example of an antihero. Gatsby's morals and cadence, it would seem, are more or less aligned with the audience's: "He smiled understandingly - much more than understandingly" (page 48). This whole paragraph is meant to communicate that Gatsby is in fact a very down-to-earth, friendly person. At the same time, though, we must take into account his wider actions - mainly the wild and raucous parties he throws each night. The parties rather contradict what most people would consider acceptable behavior. But though the action itself contradicts the audience's values, the desires bearing it are very much the readers' as well: to have fun. We should also consider that Gatsby does not seem altogether hedonistic at his parties. Nick observes that he does not drink at his parties, and Gatsby's remark, "I'm afraid I'm not a very good host" (page 48) indicates that he means for others to have fun as well. Within the rest of the book, I expect we will see further shady activities from the not-so-shady-himself Jay Gatsby.

The villain, then, is quite simply defined as the character who does things we consider wrong, and for the wrong reasons. The prime example in The Great Gatsby (though there are many) would be Tom Buchanan. Tom hardly makes a good impression when he starts on about "The Rise of the Colored Empires" (page 13), which immediately pegs him as a racist. Our opinion of Tom only sinks when we find out that "Tom's got some woman in New York" (page 15). Tom is cheating on Daisy, a character that so far we have had no reason to wish such a thing on. Tom finally solidifies his role as a hard-boiled villain when it is revealed that he has told people he can not divorce Daisy because she is Catholic and does not believe in divorce, when in fact "Daisy was not a Catholic, and [Nick] was a little shocked at the elaborateness of the lie" (page 34). This exempts Tom from any chance he had at redemption. Plainly he can not bring himself even to break it off with Daisy, likely because he knows she has done nothing to deserve what he has done to her, and thus he would come out of the divorce looking like what he is - a villain. One might expect Tom to further take on his role as the scum of the earth, and perhaps even offer some opposition to Nick or Gatsby (or both).