Monday, March 5, 2012

Final Great Gatsby Reading Journal

What was the purpose of the single appearance of Daisy and Tom's daughter?
The fact that Pammy appears precisely once in the entire novel is itself telling. Clearly Pammy is neglected, and many readers may have even forgotten that she exists. Gatsby, as Nick observes, seems to have been entirely unconvinced that she ever did exist. This neglect might then be translated to a symbol - most likely a symbol for the love between Daisy and Tom. The fact that she is neglected is reflective of the relative neglect that that relationship has suffered - again, so much that Gatsby doubts its very existence. However, her singular appearance is enough to assure us that she still exists, and that Daisy also seems to have legitimate feelings of affection for her. This could foreshadow similar revelations about Daisy and Tom's relationship, that Daisy still holds feelings for Tom, however invisible and unbelievable. The fact that Tom is never present while Pammy is could indicate two things. It could (a) clue us in that Pammy is a sort of stand-in for Tom (in terms of Daisy's affection for her) or (b) be symbolic of Tom's particular neglect of the relationship (as he is actively and remorselessly cheating on his wife).

Why did Fitzgerald choose to have the "owl-eyed man" appear at Gatsby's funeral?
From the beginning Owl-eyes had been picked out as an unusual specimen among Gatsby's partygoers. One might be inclined to think of him as "the typical drunk," but in fact there were many drunks at Gatsby's parties. Only Owl-eyes acted the way he did - with wide-eyed (perhaps a clever pun on Fitzgerald's part) enthusiasm about Gatsby. While the other party-goers regarded Gatsby with suspicion, Owl-eyes viewed him with admiration. While the other guests attended only for the drink and dancing, Owl-eyes seemed to attend out of a real enthusiasm about Gatsby, a real belief that he was a man worth being around. Perhaps those eyes were able to penetrate further than most - able to see the man behind the myth, if only in a vague format. Probably Fitzgerald wanted this character to act as a contrast to the typical guests - by showing us an example of somebody who really sincerely cared about Gatsby, the other guests are more precisely identified as phonies and crooks, who attended only for what carnal satisfaction they could take from it.

Was Fitzgerald right in ultimately making Gatsby the "loser" of this story?
One's answer to this question will ultimately depend on how romantically one is willing to view love. The tempting answer is that Gatsby should have won, that in chapter 7 Daisy should have said finally and emphatically that she did not, nor never had loved Tom, and she and Gatsby should have run off to get married and lived their lives happily ever after. But this is the fairy-tale version, and in reality human emotion is more complicated. What existed between Gatsby and Daisy five years prior can not be recovered in its entirety because the conditions can not be replicated. Even though Gatsby had made minor successes - having an affair, getting Daisy to say she loved him - he could not reach the peak they had experience five years before. That spark had been diluted, and nothing could truly rekindle it. In the end, Gatsby had to be the loser of this story. Did he deserve it? Certainly not. But it had to be so, for his cause was hopeless.


How effective was the symbolism of the “green light”?
By the ending pages of the novel it becomes fairly obvious what the green light was meant to represent – the unreasonable hope Gatsby held for his relationship with Daisy. It was that that he reached out to every night, reaching out to the love he sought to regain. It was that light that, as Nick perceived, lost its charm to Gatsby when Daisy was in his arms, as the realization slowly set in, however much he failed to admit it, that Daisy was not as he had built her up in his mind. But the symbol is not maintained well throughout much of the novel, when it very well could have been used again and again for these purposes. Furthermore, we were warned to look for meanings to the color green being used. But, unless we want to use some “universal” meaning for green, like nature or money or “go,” none of which make a terrible amount of sense, we have to go on pretenses built by other uses of green in the novel. Only two can be found. The first is the color that a bystander at first mistakenly thinks Gatsby's car is. This could be read into with questionable veracity. The only other use is more useful still – in the final pages, Nick alludes to how the “green landmass” of Manhattan must have acted as a symbol of hope for its Dutch discoverers – but comes so late as to come off almost as if it was shoved in to give quick explanation to the color. In short, Fitzgerald makes weak use of a strong symbol.

No comments:

Post a Comment