Sunday, September 18, 2011

Listening Journal 9/14/11 - "Eleanor Rigby": The Beatles vs. Dubstep

Which of these do you like better? Why (be specific)?
I feel that this a bit of an apples-to-oranges comparison. These songs, although one is based on the other, are of entirely different musical styles. Obviously, I'm going to have to ultimately pick the Beatles' original song. It's more familiar to me, the instrumentation is more reminiscent of the lyrics' melancholy, and the Beatles' version includes the full lyrics, which do a large part of the song's mood-setting.

Which of these is more pleasing to listen to? Why (be specific)?
The Beatles version is certainly more aesthetically pleasing. Dubstep's heavy bass and remixing are head-splitting and irritating to a great many people (including myself, when they're not gracefully implemented). The Beatles' version is more soothing and consistent, with a resonating bass and the Beatles' classic harmony.

No comments:

Post a Comment