Sunday, November 20, 2011

First Brave New World Reading Journal

The methods of control of society in Brave New World are quite possibly even more stunningly expansive than those exhibited in Orwell's 1984 (appropriate, perhaps, since Huxley's fictional totalitarians rule the entire world, not just a large section of it.) In Brave New World, we are introduced from the beginning to the sheer power of the world government - they control the manufacture of humanity. No longer must the government tolerate the unpredictable influence of parents (in fact, the idea of parenting is so foreign to these people that one student, upon learning of it for the first time "turned pale at the mere description and was on the point of being sick" (Huxley 49).) From the beginning, the state maintains perfect control over the course of a human's life, even going so far as to have a "Social Predestination Room." People are often born as one of a number of completely identical people known as a "Bokinovsky Group." And a social caste system is reinforced by giving "an Epsilon embryo.. an Epsilon environment as well as an Epsilon heredity" (Huxley 28).

Conflict is reduced primarily by an insistence on a "Social Body" which one is socially forbidden from ever acting contrary towards. Relationships have been reduced to the point of dumb sexual promiscuity, such that meaningful relationships are not only uncommon but frowned upon. Most importantly, the presence of the drug "soma is ubiquitous. So powerful is soma that it seems to have supplanted not only religion and alcohol as a depressant, but free thought and individual reflection as a pastime. As the World Controller of West Europe explains to a group of students in the novel, "Take a holiday from reality whenever you like and come back without so much as a headache or a mythology" (Huxley 66).

Perhaps even more so than in 1984, classifying Brave New World as either a dystopia or a utopia is strictly a matter of perspective. What may appear to us or to some character in the novel as an unlivable situation is quite visibly to most of the characters (and perhaps some of us) a perfectly desirable world. Certainly suffering appears to have been mostly destroyed, regardless of what shady methods were used to do so. Ultimately, I would make this claim: Brave New World is a dystopia, because any developed utopia is eventually revealed to be as much. From my standpoint, the creation of a utopia i9nevitably leads to the destruction of a key part of the human experience. In the case of Brave New World, it is, to Bernard, the ability "to be free to be happy in some other way" (Huxley 101). To Helmholtz Watson, it is that "what you make with [phrases] should be good too" (Huxley 81). In my mind, it is inconceivable that these problems should not arise in every utopia for which we are given significant detail, for if utopia were compatible with human character, it would have already occurred.

No comments:

Post a Comment