Something must be said first - to compare these two essays seems to be a bit fallacious. Superficially, yes, both articles address those living in poverty. But upon examination of each article in detail, they seem to be apples to oranges. Singer discusses the ethics of giving our income to those less fortunate. On the other hand, Divakaruni discusses whether attempts to effect change with our wallets do more harm than good. Certainly neither author seems to explicitly disagree with the other. In fact, Divakaruni seems all in for donation, if more for the purpose of creating education and employment opportunity than simply feeding the hungry indiscriminately. Singer describes his ethical philosophy as judging "whether acts are right or wrong based on their consequences." If anything, this is the same reasoning Divakaruni uses to prove her point: the consequences of refusing imports made by child laborers makes it more unethical than ethical.
I'll admit that there's bound to be some bias for me regarding both of these pieces. Singer sings - pun most certainly intended - the praises of giving all that one can give. Living only at one's needs, and donating all other income. I, like most other humans, am hesitant to sacrifice this much. We all love our TV, internet, books. More importantly, what's to say I'm doing harm by every cent I spend instead of donating? From my point of view, money spent can be money well spent. Singer's argument doesn't sit well with me, id or superego. I certainly understand his position, I do not vilify it at all. To give all that one can conceivably give is a noble cause. But it is not the only way to do good. If I spend money educating myself on the issues of my country or the world, am I doing a sum wrong? Singer's whole argument is a large false dilemma. "Whatever money you are spending on luxuries, not necessities, should be given away," Singer says. But are all things so easily classified as one or the other? Singer presents plenty of statistics on how much money is necessary to save a life, I applaud him for that. But there are more than one way to save a life, arguably more effective than purchasing food. Suppose I want to help start wind farms or some other initiative in some third-world country with my money? Singer certainly does not think this is the best way to donate, but from my view helping the poor to become more self-sufficient is easily as noble as giving them food directly. In fact, moreso.
Divakaruni's argument is presented as a case against traditional advances towards human rights - something that I am an avid supporter of. My bias at the beginning of her article was to dismiss arguments against such advances. But as I read further, that bias began to break down. Arguing that Divakaruni is out of touch on the issues would be absurd; she grew up exposed to the people she describes in the article. She even goes into detail regarding one such boy "who used to work in our house [in Calcutta]." Divakaruni, while applying approximately the same utilitarian ethics as Singer, avoids the false dilemma he presented by discussing what myriad things could (and must) be done in the stead of stopping child labor: give money for food, clothes, and medicine; provide education; help the governments of these countries, so that when we finally decide to let these children loose of their bondage, they are not burdens on their families and their societies. Divakaruni wins praise from me, for in less than half of Singer's length, she was able to overcome a preexisting bias. More statistics and facts do not make Singer's essay any more convincing, or even correct. They only highlight the fallacies he commits, and do all the more to show Divakaruni as more persuasive.
No comments:
Post a Comment