Showing posts with label reading response journal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reading response journal. Show all posts

Sunday, November 6, 2011

Final 1984 Reading Journal

The answers to 1984's ending lies in an understanding of what George Orwell wanted to accomplish with this book. The title provides the most obvious hint - 1984, a year in the future. Orwell is not trying to discuss modern day politics, nor is he necessarily even discussing the results of real life developments that are taking place (the book claims that the Americans invaded Britain in 1945. Orwell wrote 1984 in 1949, thus making clear that he wrote the book as a sort of progressed alternate history.) Thus it seems that Orwell's primary purpose in writing 1984 is as a warning.

It is for this reason that Big Brother is the final victor. Orwell's goal is not to set out a plan to overthrow an already-existing government that resembles that of the Party. O'Brien in fact seems to serve as an author avatar in some cases, as he explains the plan set forth in the book "is nonsense. The secret accumulation of knowledge - a gradual spread of enlightenment - ultimately a proletarian rebellion - the overthrow of the Party... It is all nonsense" (215). O'Brien is Orwell's tool for delivering the harsh realities of the reality crafted in his book, and as a result we are hardly in a position to argue that he is wrong. Possibly both Orwell and O'Brien underestimate the power of the proletarians, and perhaps some day a gradual enlightenment will occur. But the two O's are probably right - the hope of proletarian rebellion is virtually nonexistent. So long as they are ignorant they will never rebel, and until they rebel, they will always be ignorant. The Party has institutionalized one of humanities oldest catch-22's.

Winston's fate is left somewhat open, but we can take hints from the final chapter of book three. While sitting in the Chestnut Tree Cafe, Winston hears a song over the telescreen:
Under the spreading chestnut tree/ I sold you and you sold me- (241)
The verse recalls a memory Winston has of seeing the three traitors whom he knows were innocent - Jones, Aaronson, and Rutherford - at the same cafe he now sits in every day. Just as "Rutherford's ruinous face" had "eyes [that] were full of tears," (66) Winston cries when he hears the song. The implication is thus that Winston will face Jones, Aaronson, and Rutherford's fate - he will be rearrested on (this time) phony charges. However, given that Winston's treasons were less publicized than Jones, Aaronson, and Rutherford's, he will probably not be given a public trial and execution. Indeed, the final paragraphs of the book's ultimate chapter seem to indicate Winston dies just as he had anticipated - an unseen bullet through the back of the head, somewhere in the halls of the Ministry of Love. What these last paragraphs truly mean is open to interpretation, as they appear to occur outside of the normal flow of events. However, assuming they are not some sort of hallucination, this explanation seems to make the best sense of the given information.

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Reading Response Journal 10/27/11 - "The Egg" by Sherwood Anderson

1. Before marriage, the narrator's father was simple, modest, and unambitious. After marriage, he becomes more ambitious and less satisfied with the simple life he led before. This change occurs die to his new feelings of responsibility to his family, especially due to his wife's extreme responsibility to her husband and son.

2. The narrator seems to be made uncomfortable by the chickens around him, but more importantly he is disappointed by the chickens. So many eggs fail that it becomes a distant possibility that any will succeed, and when it seems that one won't fail, it does. He also seems disconcerted that any egg that produces a hen will be forced to make more eggs. In this sense, it seems that eggs are choices, and the hens contentment. Many choices will be made and fail, and those that lead to satisfaction will ultimately lead to more choices, most of them doomed.

3. His father's "grotesques" are failed eggs that he carries around with pride. Their meaning to the story is clear - his pride in them does not translate to their helpfulness in his attempts to be a good businessman. But their meaning symbolically is a bit more contentious. They could represent failed choices, choices that were obviously wrong, and yet we don't always catch on to this.Alternatively, they could represent false satisfaction, when we think we are satisfied but aren't really. In this sense, his father's parading them around might be to show the folly of being attached to them, and thus whatever it is they represent.

4. "The complete and final triumph of the egg" clearly refers to the fact that the author seems unaware of the answers about eggs. This is the final triumph of eggs, and therefore choices - the reason they continue to exist is that we can not hope to understand them. The egg's triumph over his father because he never really understands them, and choices are the same.

Thursday, October 27, 2011

Second 1984 Reading Journal

The question of why Winston finds it so difficult to swallow the Party's truth is an interesting one because Orwell clearly wrote Winston to be an unremarkable man. There's nothing very special about him to explain why he seems to feel differently about the Party. One possible explanation is that he doesn't, that everybody feels this way and that we only know that he feels this way because we have direct access to his thoughts. There are only two possible aspects of Winston that are unique: the first is the evidence. Winston has had the seemingly unique opportunity to come into contact with a piece of evidence that incontrovertibly proves that the Party's truth is not the real truth. The second is his dreams, which - while it is unlikely that he is the only person in his society that dreams - we can be reasonably sure nobody has ones exactly like them. Winston's dreams remind him of a time prior to the Revolution. This vague ability to tap into better times may allow Winston the unique ability to see through the illusion society has created for him.

Once aware of the reasons for Winston's opinions, we're then left to wonder - are his actions a form of protest? Though this depends on how one defines protest, it seems clear that in a general sense Winston's actions are out of anger towards the society he is forced to deal with. We know that he resents this society primarily for two reasons - the first being the numerous heretical and downright fanatical things he writes in his journal, chiefly "DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER;" the second being his statement to Julia: "I hate purity, I hate goodness! I don't want any virtue to exist anywhere. I want everyone to be corrupt to the bones," which indicates a strong backlash to the values supposedly promoted by the Party. Elements of Winston's actions might be interpreted more as pleasure-seeking, such as his many interactions with Julia, but it becomes clear when he meets with O'Brien that his commitment is first and foremost to rebellion, even if it means his inevitable death. He does not share Julia's wish to simply survive. Winston wants to live - however briefly - contrary to the Party.

The problem with comparing Winston's actions to any protest group today is that the two exist in very different environments. One might say what one likes about American society, but ultimately it is not nearly as oppressive as Oceania. We have no Thought Police to be constantly evaded. Thus we can come to a very positive conclusion that society today, bleak as it may sometimes be, is not quite Orwellian. We can use a very typical sample in the recent Occupy Wall Street movement. Where Winston fights for the basic ability to live as a human being, the Occupy Wall Street protesters are fighting for changes to unjust policies that ultimately they think are achievable. Are the modern protesters wrong? No, they are simply fighting for something quite different from that which Winston fights for. In turn, while Winston fights government and society at large, the Occupy Wall Street protesters are chiefly concerned with businessmen. Winston's protests are ultimately punished severely; while many Wall Street protesters have ended up under arrest, this is a consequence of perceived statutory violations, not the simple act of having a differing opinion. The medium of the protests - private acts of rebellion vs. very public demonstrations - also represents a significant difference, especially the attitudes of the public. For the most part, the public is not hostile to Occupy Wall Street, with 47% of Americans in a recent New York Times poll agreeing with the movement's basic premise. Once again, while American (and Western) society at large has a wealth of problems that are fairly pointed out by acts of protest, none of them are of the nature to require private acts like Winston's.

Monday, October 17, 2011

First 1984 Reading Journal

The government of Oceania seems to have engineered rather well their concept of a "utopia." Equality and conformity is strictly enforced. Every member of the inner party is forced mercilessly into the same basic life pattern as everyone else. Wake up at the same time; do the Physical Jerks; go to work at one or the other of the Ministries; have a bland lunch of some sort of slop; get off of work at the same time as everyone else; spend your evening at the Community Center; and retire to bed. Never is there given a moment for independent living, and attempts to do so, characterized as ownlife, are very likely to see one jailed or vaporized. The existence of a Thought Police signals wide and clear that dissent, even only in one's own head, is not tolerated whatsoever. Winston knows that he risks death by opening his journal, and by holding secret opinions contrary to the party. In Oceania, thoughtcrime IS death.

Conflict has been minimized in all ways imaginable. As stated before, dissent of opinion is strictly punished, and never appears in public life. Religion seems to have been entirely destroyed, as churches are now used as propagandist museums. The Party controls all flow of information, making the forming of dissenting opinions nigh on impossible anyway. Individual rights are characterized as contrary to happiness, and even as unnatural. This attitude is enshrined in one of the three party slogans, "Freedom is slavery." Relationships are reduced to nothingness, permitted only for the purpose of procreation to create more erstwhile slaves to the Party. So strictly is this enforced that a person is allowed to have a procreational relationship with another person if a panel can confirm that no attraction exists between the two parties whatsoever.

Happiness is forced in this society. Always one is expected to show his or her love for Big Brother, and always to wear a smile on his or her face. To do otherwise is heresy to the Party and punishable by vaporization. The distinction that makes this society a dystopia, not a utopia, is the fact that this happiness does not actually exist. The end of suffering has not actually occurred, only a disgusting facade of it. Winston reflects in Part I on how nothing about his present condition feels right, how it feels as though there should be something better. What Winston is feeling is discontent. Despite Winston's suspicions that he may be the only one who harbors his opinions, undoubtedly others in his society are discontented as well. This alone proves that he can not live in a utopia, for discontent is a form of suffering, and so long as there is suffering there is no true utopia.

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Reading Critically - Summary

Before beginning to read an essay, it is helpful to identify the possible meaning of the title; the background, training, previous works, and views of the author; and the time and place in which the essay was written. The first reading should simply be to get an understanding of the basic ideas of the author, not to analyze the essay deeply yet. It is often helpful to keep a pencil or other writing utensil nearby whilst reading an essay, so that notes and comments can be made. Other paper (perhaps a journal) can also be helpful for writing down more extended thoughts. Thinking critically on a piece should always include analysis. This term includes inference - drawing conclusions from implicit statements - and synthesis - combing ideas or parts of ideas into a new whole. Evaluation - determining the adequacy and value of a piece - may also be necessary at times.

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Reading Response Journal 8/16/11 - "Live Free and Starve", "The Singer Solution to World Poverty"

Something must be said first - to compare these two essays seems to be a bit fallacious. Superficially, yes, both articles address those living in poverty. But upon examination of each article in detail, they seem to be apples to oranges. Singer discusses the ethics of giving our income to those less fortunate. On the other hand, Divakaruni discusses whether attempts to effect change with our wallets do more harm than good. Certainly neither author seems to explicitly disagree with the other. In fact, Divakaruni seems all in for donation, if more for the purpose of creating education and employment opportunity than simply feeding the hungry indiscriminately. Singer describes his ethical philosophy as judging "whether acts are right or wrong based on their consequences." If anything, this is the same reasoning Divakaruni uses to prove her point: the consequences of refusing imports made by child laborers makes it more unethical than ethical.

I'll admit that there's bound to be some bias for me regarding both of these pieces. Singer sings - pun most certainly intended - the praises of giving all that one can give. Living only at one's needs, and donating all other income. I, like most other humans, am hesitant to sacrifice this much. We all love our TV, internet, books. More importantly, what's to say I'm doing harm by every cent I spend instead of donating? From my point of view, money spent can be money well spent. Singer's argument doesn't sit well with me, id or superego. I certainly understand his position, I do not vilify it at all. To give all that one can conceivably give is a noble cause. But it is not the only way to do good. If I spend money educating myself on the issues of my country or the world, am I doing a sum wrong? Singer's whole argument is a large false dilemma. "Whatever money you are spending on luxuries, not necessities, should be given away," Singer says. But are all things so easily classified as one or the other? Singer presents plenty of statistics on how much money is necessary to save a life, I applaud him for that. But there are more than one way to save a life, arguably more effective than purchasing food. Suppose I want to help start wind farms or some other initiative in some third-world country with my money? Singer certainly does not think this is the best way to donate, but from my view helping the poor to become more self-sufficient is easily as noble as giving them food directly. In fact, moreso.

Divakaruni's argument is presented as a case against traditional advances towards human rights - something that I am an avid supporter of. My bias at the beginning of her article was to dismiss arguments against such advances. But as I read further, that bias began to break down. Arguing that Divakaruni is out of touch on the issues would be absurd; she grew up exposed to the people she describes in the article. She even goes into detail regarding one such boy "who used to work in our house [in Calcutta]." Divakaruni, while applying approximately the same utilitarian ethics as Singer, avoids the false dilemma he presented by discussing what myriad things could (and must) be done in the stead of stopping child labor: give money for food, clothes, and medicine; provide education; help the governments of these countries, so that when we finally decide to let these children loose of their bondage, they are not burdens on their families and their societies. Divakaruni wins praise from me, for in less than half of Singer's length, she was able to overcome a preexisting bias. More statistics and facts do not make Singer's essay any more convincing, or even correct. They only highlight the fallacies he commits, and do all the more to show Divakaruni as more persuasive.