Sunday, October 30, 2011

Reading Response Journal 10/27/11 - "The Egg" by Sherwood Anderson

1. Before marriage, the narrator's father was simple, modest, and unambitious. After marriage, he becomes more ambitious and less satisfied with the simple life he led before. This change occurs die to his new feelings of responsibility to his family, especially due to his wife's extreme responsibility to her husband and son.

2. The narrator seems to be made uncomfortable by the chickens around him, but more importantly he is disappointed by the chickens. So many eggs fail that it becomes a distant possibility that any will succeed, and when it seems that one won't fail, it does. He also seems disconcerted that any egg that produces a hen will be forced to make more eggs. In this sense, it seems that eggs are choices, and the hens contentment. Many choices will be made and fail, and those that lead to satisfaction will ultimately lead to more choices, most of them doomed.

3. His father's "grotesques" are failed eggs that he carries around with pride. Their meaning to the story is clear - his pride in them does not translate to their helpfulness in his attempts to be a good businessman. But their meaning symbolically is a bit more contentious. They could represent failed choices, choices that were obviously wrong, and yet we don't always catch on to this.Alternatively, they could represent false satisfaction, when we think we are satisfied but aren't really. In this sense, his father's parading them around might be to show the folly of being attached to them, and thus whatever it is they represent.

4. "The complete and final triumph of the egg" clearly refers to the fact that the author seems unaware of the answers about eggs. This is the final triumph of eggs, and therefore choices - the reason they continue to exist is that we can not hope to understand them. The egg's triumph over his father because he never really understands them, and choices are the same.

No comments:

Post a Comment