The question of why Winston finds it so difficult to swallow the Party's truth is an interesting one because Orwell clearly wrote Winston to be an unremarkable man. There's nothing very special about him to explain why he seems to feel differently about the Party. One possible explanation is that he doesn't, that everybody feels this way and that we only know that he feels this way because we have direct access to his thoughts. There are only two possible aspects of Winston that are unique: the first is the evidence. Winston has had the seemingly unique opportunity to come into contact with a piece of evidence that incontrovertibly proves that the Party's truth is not the real truth. The second is his dreams, which - while it is unlikely that he is the only person in his society that dreams - we can be reasonably sure nobody has ones exactly like them. Winston's dreams remind him of a time prior to the Revolution. This vague ability to tap into better times may allow Winston the unique ability to see through the illusion society has created for him.
Once aware of the reasons for Winston's opinions, we're then left to wonder - are his actions a form of protest? Though this depends on how one defines protest, it seems clear that in a general sense Winston's actions are out of anger towards the society he is forced to deal with. We know that he resents this society primarily for two reasons - the first being the numerous heretical and downright fanatical things he writes in his journal, chiefly "DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER;" the second being his statement to Julia: "I hate purity, I hate goodness! I don't want any virtue to exist anywhere. I want everyone to be corrupt to the bones," which indicates a strong backlash to the values supposedly promoted by the Party. Elements of Winston's actions might be interpreted more as pleasure-seeking, such as his many interactions with Julia, but it becomes clear when he meets with O'Brien that his commitment is first and foremost to rebellion, even if it means his inevitable death. He does not share Julia's wish to simply survive. Winston wants to live - however briefly - contrary to the Party.
The problem with comparing Winston's actions to any protest group today is that the two exist in very different environments. One might say what one likes about American society, but ultimately it is not nearly as oppressive as Oceania. We have no Thought Police to be constantly evaded. Thus we can come to a very positive conclusion that society today, bleak as it may sometimes be, is not quite Orwellian. We can use a very typical sample in the recent Occupy Wall Street movement. Where Winston fights for the basic ability to live as a human being, the Occupy Wall Street protesters are fighting for changes to unjust policies that ultimately they think are achievable. Are the modern protesters wrong? No, they are simply fighting for something quite different from that which Winston fights for. In turn, while Winston fights government and society at large, the Occupy Wall Street protesters are chiefly concerned with businessmen. Winston's protests are ultimately punished severely; while many Wall Street protesters have ended up under arrest, this is a consequence of perceived statutory violations, not the simple act of having a differing opinion. The medium of the protests - private acts of rebellion vs. very public demonstrations - also represents a significant difference, especially the attitudes of the public. For the most part, the public is not hostile to Occupy Wall Street, with 47% of Americans in a recent New York Times poll agreeing with the movement's basic premise. Once again, while American (and Western) society at large has a wealth of problems that are fairly pointed out by acts of protest, none of them are of the nature to require private acts like Winston's.
No comments:
Post a Comment