Showing posts with label claims and facts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label claims and facts. Show all posts

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Quote Response 10/25/11 - Aristotle

"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it."
Aristotle here is talking about the idea of critical thought. There are two elements of critical thought - open-mindedness and criticism. Open-mindedness dictates that a person should not outright reject any claim he or she hears without giving it due consideration. This is not intellectual because it is inevitable that one will be confronted with a conclusion more valid than his or hers. The flipside of this, however, is that one should not be so open-minded that, as Richard Dawkins says, "your brain falls out." This is where criticism comes in. Every claim must be considered, yes, but it must also be properly evaluated. Otherwise, one will end up believing everything one hears. The ultimate path to the truth is giving consideration to all claims, evaluating them, and choosing the best one.               

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Art Journal 9/28/11 - "Young Life" by Bo Bartlett

Claim: The boy is wearing bright red to promote contrast in the piece.
Fact: The red of the sweater is complementary to the green of the truck directly behind him.

Claim: The placement of the deer is meant to separate the child from the adults.
Fact: The deer encloses the man and woman under it, while the boy is not enclosed.

Claim: The boy's stick represents success and a future.
Fact: The man and woman are surrounded by short stumps, while the boy has a noticeably thinner but still longer stick.

Noticeable differences exist between the boy and the adults in the picture. One of the most noticeable ones is the object the boy holds in the picture. The boy is holding a stick, an object that shows up nowhere else in the piece. The stick is a symbol for future prosperity. Notice the scattering of tree stumps around the adults in the painting. These represent the fact that the adults - implied to be poor, and possibly the parents of the young child - had their futures cut short, in contrast to the boy, whose better dressing implies a degree of hope for success in his future.