Subject
The subject of Dave Barry’s “Batting Clean-Up and Striking Out” is the oft baffling differences between men and women. These maddening variations are illustrated by Barry’s observation early on that women can “see dirt that men cannot see, dirt at the level of molecules, whereas men don’t generally notice it until it forms clumps large enough to support agriculture.” Here, Barry is setting up the (hyperbolized) contrasts between men and women that he will address throughout the piece.
Occasion
“Batting Clean-Up and Striking Out” was written during the 1980s, probably sometime shortly preceding 1988. The essay’s time of creation is displayed by Barry’s remarking on watching the World Series on TV, a pastime that would’ve been especially popular in an era when color TVs had finally become prevalent, and baseball was popular (as it had been for most of the 20th century.) The probable place of the essay’s creation is Barry’s home in Miami. Barry speaks of “his specific family unit” and having to clean his son’s bathroom. This means that he almost certainly had family on the mind at the time of writing this, and what better place for this to occur than at home?
Audience
Dave Barry’s specific audience for “Batting Clean-Up and Striking Out” is married men. The author’s target audience is exhibited by his discussion of “what often happens in [his] specific family unit.” Barry’s discussion of married life indicates that those best suited to reading the piece are those who are in a similar situation to Barry’s – married men.
The author’s general audience for the essay is American adults. The author’s general audience is shown when Barry complains of his friend Maddy, “who once invited some people, including my wife and me, for an evening of stimulating conversation and jovial companionship, which sounds fine except that this particular evening occurred during a World Series game.” This tells us two facts about Barry’s general audience. The first is that they understand relatively high vocabulary, indicating that they are educated and literate and, therefore, most likely adults. The second is that they know what the World Series is, and why it’s important. Being (somewhat confusingly) an American event, this narrows down Barry’s general audience to American adults.
Purpose
Dave Barry’s purpose in “Batting Clean-Up and Striking out” is to persuade the reader to accept and understand the differences between most men and most women. Barry’s quest to have distinctions between the majority of members of each gender be recognized and tolerated is illustrated by (after explaining the “true” cause of the Pompeii disaster), “This is one historical reason why, to this very day, men tend to do extremely little in the way of useful housework.” Here Barry is demonstrating that he understands men are feeble in some ways that women tend not to be, and that this has and should be accepted and accounted for. Barry further demonstrates hi s purpose by saying, “Soon all four of us [men] were in there, watching the Annual Fall Classic, while the women prattled away about human relationships or something.” Here, Barry gives us a resolution to his story: ultimately, the men watch their baseball game and the women talk, and everybody is presumably fine. There are no hearts broken because everybody involved ultimately recognizes those fundamental differences between the two groups.
Speaker
Dave Barry, a leading humorist in the United States, believes that women are fundamentally different from men in some ways. This belief is illustrated by Barry’s speculation that “somewhere during the growth process, a hormonal secretion takes place in women that enables them to see dirt men cannot see.” This shows that Barry believes there is something about a woman being a woman that endows her with this ability. This shows in Barry’s essay as he builds the piece around this concept that men and women have a (largely) gender-defined divide on certain aspects of life.
Dave Barry, a married man, also believes that it is not possible for men to fully acquire the skills women are endowed, or vice versa. This belief is illustrated by “I’ll always go into Robert’s bathroom, and it always looks perfectly fine. I mean, when I hear the word “filthy” used to describe a bathroom, I think about this bar where I used to hang out called Joe’s Sportsman’s Lounge, where the men’s room had bacteria you could enter in a rodeo.” Here Barry is demonstrating the gap of understanding between men and women, as he remains unable to understand what his wife finds so “filthy” about his son’s bathroom after many times of being forced to clean it. This affects the story as we see Barry display no attempts to educate women on the issues that men are aware of, but simply attempts to escape to deal with them personally.
Dave Barry’s use of device is evident in his allusion, “It was exactly like that story by Edgar Allan Poe…” Here, Barry is using information assumed to be understood by the reader (the plot of Poe’s story and, more importantly, the nature of Poe’s fiction) to execute a joke that helps to advance his point in the piece. Using these allusions makes Barry’s piece more humorous and less academic, and thus more agreeable to the average American that might read the essay.
Tone
Dave Barry articulates a sarcastic and bewildered attitude about the differences between men and women in “Batting Clean-Up and Striking Out.” These attitudes are expressed with “social gaffe”, “prattled”, and phrases like “the men said (in Latin).” The first two words here represent both tones, as Barry is using them not only to express his bewilderment at the actions of women, but also in a sarcastic tone by using words ironically outside of his normal voice. “The men said (in Latin)” represents Barry’s sarcastic sense of humor (here being used to point something out that is both obvious and unobvious) in his essay.