1. At first I assumed that the girl was just being coy or playing hard-to-get. This was based on an assumption that she could hear the boy, which evidently turned out to be incorrect. Later on I did start following what the filmmaker was trying to do, and initially assumed the girl was mute. It didn't occur to me until the end that she was deaf.
2. I believe that this is not a cultural conflict. The issue here is in the question of whether any cultures are being represented, and I don't think they are. Neither the ability nor the inability to hear are cultural attributes - they're strictly biological, whereas culture has been established in this class to be learned behavior. The man assumes that the girl has hearing, but making that assumption doesn't seem cultural as much as generically trained behavior. Most people, if raised around few or no deaf individuals, will tend to assume others have the ability. There's nothing cultural about this - it's a natural development for most humans. Even if one argues that either hearing or non-hearing is a culture, describing this as a cultural conflict diminishes the role of individual traits. There is no reason to believe that refusal to share one's deafness is a trait ubiquitous or even common in the deaf community. Most likely, this girl is shy by nature. One's nature tends to be a combination of biological and early emotional factors, and thus it's not really appropriate to call this a culture of any sort.
3. The main external conflict here is between the boy and the girl, as the former wants to be conversational, while the latter refuses.
4. The most obvious internal conflict here is the girl's conflict between wanting to talk to the boy and her embarrassment over her disability.
5. Eventually, the girl warms up to the boy and tells him of her deafness, thus resolving both her internal conflict (her desires win) and the external conflict (the boy wins).
Showing posts with label viewing journal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label viewing journal. Show all posts
Sunday, November 6, 2011
Sunday, October 30, 2011
Viewing Journal 10/24/11 - I vs. We
1. In a collectivist culture, what personality traits are likely to be considered ideal? What about an individualist culture?
In collectivist cultures, loyalty, consideration, and sacrifice are considered desirable personality traits. An individualist culture favors assertiveness, intelligence, and self-reliance as personality traits.
2. In what type of culture might elders or people who have professional distinction receive more respect and less challenge from people lower on their culture's/group's hierarchy? Explain your answer.
This more precisely describes a collectivist society. Collectivist cultures are hallmarked by hierarchy, and respect for that hierarchy from all members within it. So, in collectivist society, it is more likely that the eldest or most distinguished member of a group will be deferred to.
3. Create a specific problem a teacher may encounter when he/she moves from teaching in a collectivist culture to an individualist culture or vice versa. Explain the specific values/influences/obligations/desires caused by the clash. Propose a way for the conflict to be resolved.
A teacher in a collectivist society may be unaware of the Western notion of student individuality, that students often have different needs for education. A collectivist teacher in an individualistic society would thus need to adjust to this new consideration. He/she could resolve this by trying to communicate with students and their parents to gain a better understanding of what teaching methods are necessary.
4. What is an acquaintance? Does the word have a positive or negative connotation? Explain.
An acquaintance is a person that we are familiar with, and who is usually familiar with us, but we do not know them very well. We may know an acquaintance's name, job, or perhaps even age, but it is unlikely we have much knowledge beyond this. I tend to view the term as neutral, neither good nor bad. It's simply a matter-of-fact categorization of how we know a person.
In collectivist cultures, loyalty, consideration, and sacrifice are considered desirable personality traits. An individualist culture favors assertiveness, intelligence, and self-reliance as personality traits.
2. In what type of culture might elders or people who have professional distinction receive more respect and less challenge from people lower on their culture's/group's hierarchy? Explain your answer.
This more precisely describes a collectivist society. Collectivist cultures are hallmarked by hierarchy, and respect for that hierarchy from all members within it. So, in collectivist society, it is more likely that the eldest or most distinguished member of a group will be deferred to.
3. Create a specific problem a teacher may encounter when he/she moves from teaching in a collectivist culture to an individualist culture or vice versa. Explain the specific values/influences/obligations/desires caused by the clash. Propose a way for the conflict to be resolved.
A teacher in a collectivist society may be unaware of the Western notion of student individuality, that students often have different needs for education. A collectivist teacher in an individualistic society would thus need to adjust to this new consideration. He/she could resolve this by trying to communicate with students and their parents to gain a better understanding of what teaching methods are necessary.
4. What is an acquaintance? Does the word have a positive or negative connotation? Explain.
An acquaintance is a person that we are familiar with, and who is usually familiar with us, but we do not know them very well. We may know an acquaintance's name, job, or perhaps even age, but it is unlikely we have much knowledge beyond this. I tend to view the term as neutral, neither good nor bad. It's simply a matter-of-fact categorization of how we know a person.
Sunday, October 23, 2011
Viewing Journal 10/19/11 - Conflict
1. Identify the conflict. Is this an internal or external conflict?
The conflict here is between Western and Islamic cultural values. This is an external conflict, as each belligerent is outside the other.
2. How/Why does globalization create conflict? In the speaker's opinion, globalization has flown in only one direction what does she mean by this?
Globalization causes contact and intermingling between cultures that have developed previously separate from one another. Distinct values exist in each culture, and often these values contradict one another, creating conflict. The speaker means, by saying that globalization has flown in one direction, that influence from the West has affected the Muslim world, but not vice-versa.
3. Although the speaker feels globalization has been one-sided, she notes there has been one benefit related to the process. What benefit does she mention?
The benefit she mentions is the gaining of new role models for Muslim women. From the West, examples such as Sandra Day O'Connor and Oprah Winfrey empower these women and garner respect from them for Western values. This gives women in the East access to a larger variety of values to take into consideration.
4. The speaker says Muslims and westerners live by/are obligated to two different sources of truth. What two sources (two texts) does she mention?
The speaker identifies Muslims' source of truth as the Qur'an, and Americans' as the Constitution.
The conflict here is between Western and Islamic cultural values. This is an external conflict, as each belligerent is outside the other.
2. How/Why does globalization create conflict? In the speaker's opinion, globalization has flown in only one direction what does she mean by this?
Globalization causes contact and intermingling between cultures that have developed previously separate from one another. Distinct values exist in each culture, and often these values contradict one another, creating conflict. The speaker means, by saying that globalization has flown in one direction, that influence from the West has affected the Muslim world, but not vice-versa.
3. Although the speaker feels globalization has been one-sided, she notes there has been one benefit related to the process. What benefit does she mention?
The benefit she mentions is the gaining of new role models for Muslim women. From the West, examples such as Sandra Day O'Connor and Oprah Winfrey empower these women and garner respect from them for Western values. This gives women in the East access to a larger variety of values to take into consideration.
4. The speaker says Muslims and westerners live by/are obligated to two different sources of truth. What two sources (two texts) does she mention?
The speaker identifies Muslims' source of truth as the Qur'an, and Americans' as the Constitution.
Sunday, October 2, 2011
Viewing Journal 9/19/11 - Accents & Voice
1. What is voice in literature? What writing devices are used to create it?
Voice is the way in which we express our individuality through writing. By necessity, every voice should be distinct. A person's voice is most often created by word choice and sentence structure. The words we use reflect greatly on our voice, as do the ways in which we choose to organize those words. Approach to a subject is also an element of voice, as promptness vs. wordiness will differ.
2. Write a sentence or sentences about a topic of your choice. Then explain how that example reflects your own voice. What devices from #1 did you use?
Olivia has in her possession one of the most peculiar books I've ever encountered, It is the only book I will likely ever see to compare a face to a cabbage.
These sentences reflect my voice in word choice (especially the use of rather overly complex phrasings) as well as general approach (making a general statement and following it with more detail.)
3. According to the documentary, people in eastern Kentucky talk around a subject. Identify a topic you would talk around, and explain why you would handle the topic in that manner.
A subject I might talk around would be telling a story. I have an unfortunate compulsion to give as many details as possible, so I spend a lot of time giving background detail before discussing the actual event. Part of this is out of a concern that others won't understand the story without these details, but my general desire for something to feel complete is probably also at fault for this.
4. Why is voice important in nonfiction? What are some things we normally avoid in academic essays?
Voice is important in nonfiction to establish legitimacy. If I speak on an academic topic with the voice of a petulant child, my ideas will not be accurately conveyed to my audience. Using mature wording and straightforward structure allows the ideas to be more clearly communicated to an academic audience.
5. What are some ways we can develop our own voices?
We can develop our voices by expanding our vocabulary to more acceptable language and by studying our audience in such a way that we mimic the speech most relevant to them.
Voice is the way in which we express our individuality through writing. By necessity, every voice should be distinct. A person's voice is most often created by word choice and sentence structure. The words we use reflect greatly on our voice, as do the ways in which we choose to organize those words. Approach to a subject is also an element of voice, as promptness vs. wordiness will differ.
2. Write a sentence or sentences about a topic of your choice. Then explain how that example reflects your own voice. What devices from #1 did you use?
Olivia has in her possession one of the most peculiar books I've ever encountered, It is the only book I will likely ever see to compare a face to a cabbage.
These sentences reflect my voice in word choice (especially the use of rather overly complex phrasings) as well as general approach (making a general statement and following it with more detail.)
3. According to the documentary, people in eastern Kentucky talk around a subject. Identify a topic you would talk around, and explain why you would handle the topic in that manner.
A subject I might talk around would be telling a story. I have an unfortunate compulsion to give as many details as possible, so I spend a lot of time giving background detail before discussing the actual event. Part of this is out of a concern that others won't understand the story without these details, but my general desire for something to feel complete is probably also at fault for this.
4. Why is voice important in nonfiction? What are some things we normally avoid in academic essays?
Voice is important in nonfiction to establish legitimacy. If I speak on an academic topic with the voice of a petulant child, my ideas will not be accurately conveyed to my audience. Using mature wording and straightforward structure allows the ideas to be more clearly communicated to an academic audience.
5. What are some ways we can develop our own voices?
We can develop our voices by expanding our vocabulary to more acceptable language and by studying our audience in such a way that we mimic the speech most relevant to them.
Sunday, September 11, 2011
Viewing Journal 9/9/11 - "Sign Language"
What single effect did you get from this short film?
The film is about being able to find the finer details in what may seem like an otherwise bleak scenario.
Give 3 specific things that led you to that single effect.
I would have tried to manipulate the lighting to put better lighting on main character and the girl. I feel that would have greater emphasized the finding detail aspect by showing the important things more obviously.
The film is about being able to find the finer details in what may seem like an otherwise bleak scenario.
Give 3 specific things that led you to that single effect.
- The camera is often focused on the face of Ben, allowing us to see the details of his face, while simultaneously creating the ironic effect of keeping us from viewing any other details of his surroundings.
- When the camera shows others, it shows them at a distance, but better focused than their surroundings.
- The music is very subtle and unobtrusive, so that it sets a mood but doesn't really draw attention. However, we still notice when the music is gone. It also becomes more noticeable as Ben gets the look of realization on his face at the end that he needs to talk to the girl.
I would have tried to manipulate the lighting to put better lighting on main character and the girl. I feel that would have greater emphasized the finding detail aspect by showing the important things more obviously.
Sunday, August 28, 2011
Viewing Journal 8/22/11 - Wilco & the Creative Process
Summarize Wilco's approach to creating a song.
The band begins by creating a simple concept for the song. They create it in the most straightforward, perhaps uninteresting way possible. This gives them a general idea of what they want the song to be. They then proceed to tear down that early build, "deconstructing" the song that they have created to find new, more creative ways to approach it. At that point they can proceed to reconstruct the song with the new ideas included.
What is your creative process for writing?
I can admit to not having much of a creative process. If I set about to writing something, the first thing I'll uusally do is research, to make sure that I have all the knowledge I feel will be necessary to make the piece the best it can be. Then I will run through an outline in my head, trying to organize how I want the piece to break down. At times, I may come up with some brilliant point to make, and I will try to include that in my piece. At that point, I allow myself to sit down, guided by my mental outline, and let my thoughts flow into the piece.
The reason I don't have a more strict creative process is that I've simply never felt the need for one. My writing has always been of sound quality without one, and I don't really write for pleasure, so I don't feel the need to push myself on writing outside of academic needs.
The band begins by creating a simple concept for the song. They create it in the most straightforward, perhaps uninteresting way possible. This gives them a general idea of what they want the song to be. They then proceed to tear down that early build, "deconstructing" the song that they have created to find new, more creative ways to approach it. At that point they can proceed to reconstruct the song with the new ideas included.
What is your creative process for writing?
I can admit to not having much of a creative process. If I set about to writing something, the first thing I'll uusally do is research, to make sure that I have all the knowledge I feel will be necessary to make the piece the best it can be. Then I will run through an outline in my head, trying to organize how I want the piece to break down. At times, I may come up with some brilliant point to make, and I will try to include that in my piece. At that point, I allow myself to sit down, guided by my mental outline, and let my thoughts flow into the piece.
The reason I don't have a more strict creative process is that I've simply never felt the need for one. My writing has always been of sound quality without one, and I don't really write for pleasure, so I don't feel the need to push myself on writing outside of academic needs.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)