Overt message?
Oil and competition allow for a better society.
Covert message?
Oil companies should not be questioned because they produce benefits for all.
Why is it propaganda? Specific techniques?
The film is essentially making assertions based on "American values" to convince the viewer that oil companies work for the common man. Never is this stated outright, but the ideas of oil and competition are treated with reverence to butter the audience up for this idea. The film continually uses glittering generalities, characterizing the oil industry as contributing to "freedom" and "standard of living" and "security."
Monday, January 16, 2012
Sunday, January 8, 2012
Propaganda (WWII 1941-1945) - 1/5/12
What is the overt message?
The poster implores the viewer to eat less bread tin order to support the war effort.
What is the covert message?
The covert message seems to affirm a woman's "place" in society - the kitchen, which this poster claims is the key to victory. Notice instead of opting for a non-occupied or co-gender image, the poster utilizes the image of a woman cooking, thus indicating that specifically women are expected to "help their country" by working in the kitchen.
How does the disparity in the two of these make it propaganda?
The poster conceals itself as informative - the kitchen is the key to victory. Eating less bread is simply framed as a recommendation based on these "facts." In reality, the fact is presented in such a way to convince the audience of something that is not being stated directly, in this case that women ought to help their country by spending their efforts in the kitchen.
The poster implores the viewer to eat less bread tin order to support the war effort.
What is the covert message?
The covert message seems to affirm a woman's "place" in society - the kitchen, which this poster claims is the key to victory. Notice instead of opting for a non-occupied or co-gender image, the poster utilizes the image of a woman cooking, thus indicating that specifically women are expected to "help their country" by working in the kitchen.
How does the disparity in the two of these make it propaganda?
The poster conceals itself as informative - the kitchen is the key to victory. Eating less bread is simply framed as a recommendation based on these "facts." In reality, the fact is presented in such a way to convince the audience of something that is not being stated directly, in this case that women ought to help their country by spending their efforts in the kitchen.
Listening Journal 1/4/12 - "Clampdown" by The Clash
1. What is the song about? How do you know?
The song is about authority, specifically giving in to authority. We can see this in the continual repetition of the phrase "working for the clampdown." While the "clampdown" is never explicitly definied, it seems to be the manifestation of authority and society "clamping down" on one's individuality. As the song says, "No man born with a living soul/Can be working for the clampdown." Thus it seems that in some way the clampdown destroys individuality or the living soul."
2. What musical elements add to your lyrical interpretation?
Musical elements of songs often represent the opinion of the artist towards the topic of the lyrics. Combining this with an understanding of who the artist is can give a better understanding of what exactly the lyrics are discussing. The Clash are often viewed as one of the pioneering bands of the punk tradition that began in the 70s and 80s. This punk culture put strong emphasis on resistance of authority. Now, combine this with the musical elements. The chorus line repeated throughout the song, "working for the clampdown," seems almost as though it is a repeated resistance against something, then forced back down. However it keeps coming back. Other elements like this can be found in the short riff that occurs at the end of several lines and the cymbal strikes that interrupt the otherwise steady beat of the song. All in all, the music of this song serves to confirm that the song deals with rebellion against something - based on The Clash's background, almost certainly authority.
3. What in the song relates to propaganda/rhetoric/persuasion/argument?
Overt propaganda references are made in the first verse, which seems to make allusions to Nazi propaganda. References to posters, an easily recognized form of propaganda, are used. As a whole, however, the ambiguous "you" in the lyrics seems to have become a victim of propaganda, slowly and covertly converted to "working for the clampdown," until eventually he has "someone to boss around/Make ya feel big now."
The song is about authority, specifically giving in to authority. We can see this in the continual repetition of the phrase "working for the clampdown." While the "clampdown" is never explicitly definied, it seems to be the manifestation of authority and society "clamping down" on one's individuality. As the song says, "No man born with a living soul/Can be working for the clampdown." Thus it seems that in some way the clampdown destroys individuality or the living soul."
2. What musical elements add to your lyrical interpretation?
Musical elements of songs often represent the opinion of the artist towards the topic of the lyrics. Combining this with an understanding of who the artist is can give a better understanding of what exactly the lyrics are discussing. The Clash are often viewed as one of the pioneering bands of the punk tradition that began in the 70s and 80s. This punk culture put strong emphasis on resistance of authority. Now, combine this with the musical elements. The chorus line repeated throughout the song, "working for the clampdown," seems almost as though it is a repeated resistance against something, then forced back down. However it keeps coming back. Other elements like this can be found in the short riff that occurs at the end of several lines and the cymbal strikes that interrupt the otherwise steady beat of the song. All in all, the music of this song serves to confirm that the song deals with rebellion against something - based on The Clash's background, almost certainly authority.
3. What in the song relates to propaganda/rhetoric/persuasion/argument?
Overt propaganda references are made in the first verse, which seems to make allusions to Nazi propaganda. References to posters, an easily recognized form of propaganda, are used. As a whole, however, the ambiguous "you" in the lyrics seems to have become a victim of propaganda, slowly and covertly converted to "working for the clampdown," until eventually he has "someone to boss around/Make ya feel big now."
Tuesday, January 3, 2012
Propaganda, Persuasion, Rhetoric, and Argument (G, H, I)
Four Quotes: #373, 392, 435, 499
Of all these quotes, one that stood out particularly well to me was #499, which follows: "The
biggest danger I encountered in my years as an editor was a reflective cynicism among some
reporters that led them to assume they knew what a story was about, before they had actually done
the reporting. They would begin with an assumption of who the good guys and the bad guys were,
and then organize the facts around that hypothesis. Sometimes, reporters were so confident about
their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to
contact the 'bad guys.'" --David Ignatius
The phenomenon that Ignatius describes is most commonly referred to as confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is the natural tendency of the incautious mind to seek out only details which confirm its previously formed opinions, or else to interpret new information consistently in a way that supports those opinions. Confirmation bias is common to most people. Even the most discerning sketpics commit it from time to time without realizing it. Journalists, then, are no exception. They are subject to the same faults as most human beings, even if we would prefer them not to be.
What comes of a journalist's confirmation bias is something different however. A journalist is in a unique position to affect the views of large groups of people - depending on readership, perhaps millions of people. As a result, what may be an unintentional act of confirmation bias can soon become indistinguishable from rhetoric and propaganda.
As Mr. Ignatius notes, reporters often have a preconceived notion of a story's "good guys" and "bad guys." They would thus be expected to reflect this in their language and description of the story. Confirmation bias then translates into something closely resembling rhetorical language. In a story about the debt crisis, a liberal reporter may describe the Republicans as "stubbornly resisting compromise" and the Democrats as "persistent." While this might be purposeful, the journalist may as easily be given the benefit of the doubt as simply subconsciously biased. He/she thus uses words in a way that reflects his/her own viewpoint on the issue, and thus acts to persuade the audience in his/her favor, all without being conscious that this is what he/she is doing.
Furthermore, this confirmation bias may go as far as a withholding of information. Mr. Ignatius observes that "Sometimes, reporters were so confident about their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to contact the 'bad guys.'" Withholding of information can come in two flavors. Misinformation, or accidental withholding, occurs when the informing party is aware the withheld information exists. If a friend tells me we have an eight page essay due tomorrow, and doesn't know that it's actually supposed to be triple-spaced, I have been misinformed. Disinformation, however, occurs when the informing party knows they are withholding information, and does so for a purpose. If my friend told me about the eight page essay, but not the triple-spacing, because she was pulling an incredibly cruel prank on me, that would be disinformation. The two are often difficult to discern. Are the numerous reporting flaws on Fox News that have been pointed out over the years innocent misinformation or calculated disinformation? More importantly, does it matter? While our working definition of propaganda should imply that it is purposeful, does intent make a difference? A reporter may innocently forget to contact a "bad guy" due to confirmation bias, but are the effects different than if he had omitted that party's opinion to push a point of view? In either case, the audience is told something that may not fully represent the truth, and thus is likely to believe what the author believes. Confirmation bias then, while not entirely the same as propaganda, can produce nearly identical results.
Of all these quotes, one that stood out particularly well to me was #499, which follows: "The
biggest danger I encountered in my years as an editor was a reflective cynicism among some
reporters that led them to assume they knew what a story was about, before they had actually done
the reporting. They would begin with an assumption of who the good guys and the bad guys were,
and then organize the facts around that hypothesis. Sometimes, reporters were so confident about
their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to
contact the 'bad guys.'" --David Ignatius
The phenomenon that Ignatius describes is most commonly referred to as confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is the natural tendency of the incautious mind to seek out only details which confirm its previously formed opinions, or else to interpret new information consistently in a way that supports those opinions. Confirmation bias is common to most people. Even the most discerning sketpics commit it from time to time without realizing it. Journalists, then, are no exception. They are subject to the same faults as most human beings, even if we would prefer them not to be.
What comes of a journalist's confirmation bias is something different however. A journalist is in a unique position to affect the views of large groups of people - depending on readership, perhaps millions of people. As a result, what may be an unintentional act of confirmation bias can soon become indistinguishable from rhetoric and propaganda.
As Mr. Ignatius notes, reporters often have a preconceived notion of a story's "good guys" and "bad guys." They would thus be expected to reflect this in their language and description of the story. Confirmation bias then translates into something closely resembling rhetorical language. In a story about the debt crisis, a liberal reporter may describe the Republicans as "stubbornly resisting compromise" and the Democrats as "persistent." While this might be purposeful, the journalist may as easily be given the benefit of the doubt as simply subconsciously biased. He/she thus uses words in a way that reflects his/her own viewpoint on the issue, and thus acts to persuade the audience in his/her favor, all without being conscious that this is what he/she is doing.
Furthermore, this confirmation bias may go as far as a withholding of information. Mr. Ignatius observes that "Sometimes, reporters were so confident about their a priori hypotheses that they would make only the most perfunctory, last-minute efforts to contact the 'bad guys.'" Withholding of information can come in two flavors. Misinformation, or accidental withholding, occurs when the informing party is aware the withheld information exists. If a friend tells me we have an eight page essay due tomorrow, and doesn't know that it's actually supposed to be triple-spaced, I have been misinformed. Disinformation, however, occurs when the informing party knows they are withholding information, and does so for a purpose. If my friend told me about the eight page essay, but not the triple-spacing, because she was pulling an incredibly cruel prank on me, that would be disinformation. The two are often difficult to discern. Are the numerous reporting flaws on Fox News that have been pointed out over the years innocent misinformation or calculated disinformation? More importantly, does it matter? While our working definition of propaganda should imply that it is purposeful, does intent make a difference? A reporter may innocently forget to contact a "bad guy" due to confirmation bias, but are the effects different than if he had omitted that party's opinion to push a point of view? In either case, the audience is told something that may not fully represent the truth, and thus is likely to believe what the author believes. Confirmation bias then, while not entirely the same as propaganda, can produce nearly identical results.
Sunday, December 11, 2011
Art Journal 12/1/11 - "Communist Utopia" by Thomas Hornung
What about this painting indicates Communism?
The setting is a decrepit, depressed gray landscape, an image often associated with the oppressive society Communism has been historically known to create. This gray monochrome is occasionally interrupted by patches of red - red being a color associated with Communism. Furthermore, there are eyes all over, watching the figure, which can be connected to the lack of privacy in most implemented Communistic societies.
What is the artist's view on Communism?
The artist views Communism as demoralizing and dehumanizing - the gray, broken landscape in the painting represents not only a horrible decay brought on by poor central management, but also the despair present in the mind of the person in the painting. The unsettling images of the eye give a clear negative impression while, more deeply, making a statement about the omnipresence of surveillance in a Communist society, as the painter sees it. Finally, notice that the figure is positioned in such a way that we can not see his face - the painter likely means to indicate to us that Communism erases individuality.
Explain the title.
The title is probably meant to be ironic, saying that with Communism this is the type of "utopia" we will get - one of decay and distrust. This usage of the title is a clear jab at those who would claim that Communism does create a utopia. Alternatively, the title could be an example of alternate truth - the title is true, but not in the way that we normally read it. In this case it may be true in the sense that this isn't a utopia brought about communism, but rather a utopia for communists - in this case, the painter would essentially be accusing Communist leaders of purposefully creating this sort of dystopic society.
The setting is a decrepit, depressed gray landscape, an image often associated with the oppressive society Communism has been historically known to create. This gray monochrome is occasionally interrupted by patches of red - red being a color associated with Communism. Furthermore, there are eyes all over, watching the figure, which can be connected to the lack of privacy in most implemented Communistic societies.
What is the artist's view on Communism?
The artist views Communism as demoralizing and dehumanizing - the gray, broken landscape in the painting represents not only a horrible decay brought on by poor central management, but also the despair present in the mind of the person in the painting. The unsettling images of the eye give a clear negative impression while, more deeply, making a statement about the omnipresence of surveillance in a Communist society, as the painter sees it. Finally, notice that the figure is positioned in such a way that we can not see his face - the painter likely means to indicate to us that Communism erases individuality.
Explain the title.
The title is probably meant to be ironic, saying that with Communism this is the type of "utopia" we will get - one of decay and distrust. This usage of the title is a clear jab at those who would claim that Communism does create a utopia. Alternatively, the title could be an example of alternate truth - the title is true, but not in the way that we normally read it. In this case it may be true in the sense that this isn't a utopia brought about communism, but rather a utopia for communists - in this case, the painter would essentially be accusing Communist leaders of purposefully creating this sort of dystopic society.
Listening Journal 11/28/11 - "Don't You Want Me?" by The Human League
1. What is the subject matter?
The song depicts a couple, who have been together "for five years." It seems that the man somehow got the woman's career on track, as he says, "I picked you up, turned you around, out you back on your feet." The woman, however, believes hi role was exaggerated, saying, "But even then I knew I'd find a much better place/Either with or without you."
2. What is the difference between the 2 sides of the story?
The man believes the woman's success was due to him, saying he "turned [her] into something new." The woman disagrees, saying her success was inevitably going to occur before she met him.
3. With who do you side and why?
It's hard to say that I side with either of these characters, given the sparsity of detail that we have. The song doesn't provide detail enough to tell which character is right. If the man is right, the woman could be viewed as acting ungrateful and unjustly spurning her long-time lover. On the other hand, if the woman is right, the man comes off as conceited, controlling, and pathetic in his attempts to keep her with him. Ultimately our judgment of whether his pleas are justified (though admittedly his threat to "put her back" is disconcerting regardless of who's right) is impaired by our utter lack of real details on these two characters' history.
The song depicts a couple, who have been together "for five years." It seems that the man somehow got the woman's career on track, as he says, "I picked you up, turned you around, out you back on your feet." The woman, however, believes hi role was exaggerated, saying, "But even then I knew I'd find a much better place/Either with or without you."
2. What is the difference between the 2 sides of the story?
The man believes the woman's success was due to him, saying he "turned [her] into something new." The woman disagrees, saying her success was inevitably going to occur before she met him.
3. With who do you side and why?
It's hard to say that I side with either of these characters, given the sparsity of detail that we have. The song doesn't provide detail enough to tell which character is right. If the man is right, the woman could be viewed as acting ungrateful and unjustly spurning her long-time lover. On the other hand, if the woman is right, the man comes off as conceited, controlling, and pathetic in his attempts to keep her with him. Ultimately our judgment of whether his pleas are justified (though admittedly his threat to "put her back" is disconcerting regardless of who's right) is impaired by our utter lack of real details on these two characters' history.
Monday, December 5, 2011
Final Brave New World Reading Journal
1. Does Aldous Huxley seem more to agree with Mustafa Mond or John the Savage, especially considering the ending of the book?
2. What, thematically, is Huxley trying to tell us with his persistent use of Shakespeare? What does "brave new world" ultimately mean?
3. How do the different objectives of the world governments in 1984 and Brave New World necessitate their different governing styles?
2. What, thematically, is Huxley trying to tell us with his persistent use of Shakespeare? What does "brave new world" ultimately mean?
3. How do the different objectives of the world governments in 1984 and Brave New World necessitate their different governing styles?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)