Tuesday, September 6, 2011

SOAPSTone - "Shooting an Elephant" by George Orwell

Subject
The subject of George Orwell’s “Shooting an Elephant” is British imperialism in India. The oppression of the Indian natives by the British government is illustrated by Orwell’s remark early on that “[he] was all for the Burmese and all against their oppressors, the British.” Here, Orwell is establishing that the main issue he is concerned with is the subjugation of the Indians. This fits the setting – 1920’s colonial Burma - as well as the issue at hand - involving Orwell’s duties as a British policeman in India.


Occasion
“Shooting an Elephant” was written during the 1930s, during the British colonial era in India. The essay’s time of creation is exhibited by Orwell’s statement that at the time, “in an aimless, petty kind of way anti-European feeling was very bitter.” He continues, “Nobody had the guts to raise a riot.” This indicates that it is indeed during the colonial era. Knowing a bit of Orwell’s history makes it easy to pinpoint this in the ‘30s, along with the fact that no rebellion is going on, indicating that at this time the large Indian independence movements of figures such as Mohandas Gandhi had not yet begun. The probable place of the essay’s creation is England. Based on the first line of the essay “In Moulmein, in lower Burma, I was hated by large numbers of people,” we can infer that while the setting is in fact Burma, this essay was written outside of Burma. Given that Orwell was an English citizen, it is most likely that he wrote the piece itself while in England.

The time and place of the essay’s creation influence the essay by giving Orwell a setting in which to reflect on his feelings in the past and what they mean. Orwell states that “[he] could get nothing into perspective. [He] was young and ill-educated and [he] had had to think out [his] problems in the utter silence that is imposed on every Englishman in the East.” Here he is remarking quite plainly that the time and place of the events themselves were not the optimal setting to write this essay. Once Orwell became older, wiser, and more able to express himself, as he was during the 1930’s, back home in England, he was able to put his thoughts on the incident described in the essay, and on imperialism in general, to paper.


Audience
George Orwell’s specific audience for “Shooting an Elephant” is the middle and upper class of British society. The author’s target audience is exhibited by his statement of opinion that “[he] thought of the British Raj as an unbreakable tyranny, as something clamped down, in saecula saeculorum, upon the will of prostrate peoples.” This demonstrates that in a specific sense, Orwell is dealing with the British Empire and its evils. This message would of course be most relevant to British citizens, and the sort that would read this essay would inevitably be those of higher birth, who are able to get a good enough education to read essays such as this.

The author’s general audience for the essay is all citizens of what might be considered an empire - this can include Americans, Britons, Frenchmen, Spaniards, and Soviets, among others. The author’s general audience is shown by another of Orwell’s statements of opinion that “[he] had already made up [his] mind that imperialism was an evil thing and the sooner [he] chucked up [his] job and got out of it the better.” In this sentence, we should notice that Orwell does not say “British Imperialism” or “the Raj” or something to that effect. Instead he addresses in the simplest terms “imperialism.” Orwell is showing here that he is not only concerned with British imperialism, but with imperialism in all forms. Thus, whether part of his real target audience or not, all those people inhabiting an empire might benefit from Orwell’s essay.

Purpose
George Orwell’s purpose in “Shooting an Elephant” is to persuade people to oppose imperialism. Orwell’s desire for a cessation to imperialism is revealed best by his saying, “I perceived in this moment that when the white man turns tyrant it is his own freedom that he destroys.” Here, Orwell states in no uncertain terms the cost of maintaining an empire. Inevitably one’s own freedom is forfeited in continual pursuit of maintain power. The purpose is further articulated by the last sentence of the essay, “I often wondered whether any of the others grasped that I had done it solely to avoid looking a fool.” Here Orwell is reminding us that ultimately it was not of his own free will that he had killed the elephant, but rather that he was forced to out of the necessity imposed by imperialism.


Speaker
George Orwell, a democratic socialist, believes that all men are equals. This value is illustrated by Orwell’s memory of “The wretched prisoners huddling in the stinking cages of the lock-ups, the grey, cowed faces of the long-term convicts, the scarred buttocks of the men who had been Bogged with bamboos – all these oppressed [him] with an intolerable sense of guilt.” Here Orwell is demonstrating his compassion for all men, regardless of their skin color, and the abhorrence he feels for treating any of them as inferior. This influences the essay by causing Orwell’s initial abhorrence of imperialism, because he feels that it is unfair to those being subjugated.

Orwell, a noted activist for social justice, also believes that freedom is cardinal to the happiness of human beings. This value is illustrated by Orwell’s statement, speaking of the dying elephant he has just killed, “In the end I could not stand it any longer and went away.” Here we see that Orwell is made deeply unhappy by the choices he has been forced to make as his freedom has been robbed from him by the imperialistic paradigm. Orwell can barely live with himself after being forced to do something so deeply upsetting. This value influences the essay by bestowing upon Orwell his main argument – that freedom is destroyed under imperialism. Because Orwell values freedom so much, he sees its destruction as a perfect argument against the continuation of colonialization.

Orwell’s use of imagery is evident in his description of the elephant as he shoots it, “He looked suddenly stricken, shrunken, immensely old, as though the frightful impact of the bullet had paralysed him without knocking him down.” Orwell’s masterful use of imagery allows his persuasiveness to grow, especially as it concerns people who may not otherwise be aware of the horrors they inflict upon the world.

Orwell’s use of symbolism is evident in his description of the murdered coolie, “He was lying on his belly with arms crucified and head sharply twisted to one side.” Note that Orwell describes the coolie’s arms as “crucified”, drawing a clear comparison to Christ. Orwell is using the coolie as a symbol for the Burmese that have been killed, persecuted, and generally downtrodden by the British rule. His unusually graphic description of the coolie’s corpse is meant to attract sympathy to the coolie, thus persuading readers of the evils of imperialism.


Tone
George Orwell exhibits a mournful and disapproving attitude about British imperialism in “Shooting an Elephant.” These attitudes are expressed by “imperialism was an evil thing,” “despotic governments,” and “dreadful.” The first two express very simply Orwell’s strong disapproval of colonialization, as he uses language that belittles and demonizes it. The last example demonstrates Orwell’s mournful attitude towards the effects of the imperialism, as he remarks of the dying elephant’s state. This tone serves the purpose of getting the readers to feel similarly about the subjugation of India and other lands. This is supported by Orwell’s assessment of the effects of imperialism on the European, just following his statement on the destruction of freedom. “[The white man] becomes a sort of hollow, posing dummy,” he says. Here Orwell is using his tone language, language that sounds simultaneously mournful and disapproving, to communicate his most important rhetoric – that the destruction of others’ freedom comes with the destruction of one’s own freedom.

1 comment:

  1. For your first attempt at the full SOAPSTone this is a fantastic job. Your support for each claim is accurate and explained. Keep digging, and don't be afraid to make absurd claims that you can only partially back up.

    ReplyDelete