Sunday, January 29, 2012

50 POSTS!!!!

I can't believe we made it to this wonderful milestone. I'd like to thank all four of my loyal followers: Mr. Behler for grading these 50 posts silently and diligently, my friends Bay and Sarah for always supporting me, and Ms. Koutsounis for continuing to show her loyalty despite not having taught this class for about two months. I'd also like to thank the Academy and all my other wonderful teachers, as well as my parents for raising me so well. I couldn't have done this without all of you.

Mencken vs. Kroll: Who Was More Persuasive?

In making this comparison we are given a relatively simple task - both of these authors rely on a core pathos appeal to make their argument. Neither author tries to argue that the death penalty deters criminals, that it reduces crime rates, etc. Similarly, neither spends much time, if any, appealing to their own credibility or anybody else's who may have a say on the issue. Each author's argument essentially centers on one idea - how the death penalty emotionally affects those involved. The question then becomes: Who creates a more emotionally appealing argument, Mencken or Kroll? In answering this there is no doubt: Kroll creates the more appealing piece. From the beginning Mencken comes off as unsympathetic - he is dismissive and arrogant, and makes no attempt to apologize for it. In contrast, Kroll's piece tactfully gathers sympathy in part by declining to comment on the innocence or guilt, the right or wrong of his friend. Kroll's piece is emotion at its best. Even the most impartial of readers will find it hard to ignore the pain and horror Kroll experiences. Mencken's piece, by contrast, is emotion at its worst. Mencken focuses not on sympathetic and genuine emotion but on a cold argument that appeals to the emotions we all would prefer not to give into. Comparing these two essays is a bit like comparing Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X. One focused on positive emotions like hope and love and inspired sympathy in his audience. The other focused on negatives like revenge and anger, and inspired fear even from those who agreed with him. Which of these figures is remembered more fondly? Mr. King of course. History and literature both show that appeals to positive pathos rather consistently beat out appeals to negative.

Listening Journal 1/25/12 - "Sixteen Military Wives" by The Decemberists

What is this song about?
The song is about people becoming numbers; numbers are repeated throughout the song - "sixteen military wives," "fifteen celebrity minds," "fourteen cannibal kings." The chorus describes the way in which society allows this to go on entirely under its nose and, in fact, seems to approve of it.

What is the theme of this song?
It seems to me that that this song wants us to think about indifference and willful ignorance, perhaps the adage "ignorance is bliss." The happy pace and melody of the song is explained well when we think about "the anchorman on TV" who goes "Ladedadeda." The song asks us to think about how the lyrics affect us when we look at their details. Sixteen military wives inspire indifference. It's just a number after all, and this allows us, along with the upbeat music, to listen to the song as something happy on a shallow level. But what about when we look at the details? "Seventeen company men/Out of which only  twelve will make it back again." There are painful truths behind these numbers, and we have to reconsider whether we are being indifferent to the details behind these numbers.

Listening Journal 1/23/12 - "Race for the Prize" by The Flaming Lips

The song appears to me to want the listener to think about the lengths people will go to for success, and the motivations behind them. In listening to the song, there is a definite "soaring" feel to the composition. The tones are high and have a relatively upbeat wind through the song. But on so many occasions, as we enter the chorus, the breeze stops. It's noticeable to the listener, almost lamentable, as if the kind summer breeze had suddenly dropped away. We're left to wonder where it went - several times in fact - and this bittersweet ride is what helps us to understand our theme. The lyrics further reflect this bittersweet attitude: the scientists are "racing for the good of all mankind," a noble cause to be sure. But the lyrics characterize doubt in this same nobility: "But it's so dangerous/But they're determined." The chorus, accompanied by the aforementioned musical nadir, clears up our theme considerably: "Theirs is to win/If it kills them." Our enjoyment of the upward climb to success is interrupted by this bitter twinge of reality and doubt. How far must humans be willing to go to achieve their dreams?

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

JFK Inauguration Speech Fallacy

1. Write a quote from the speech that commits a fallacy.
"If a free society cannot help the many who are poor, it cannot save the few who are rich."


2. Tell what fallacy it commits and explain why it is guilty of committing that logical flaw.
This is a non sequitur. Whether or not we can feed the poor has no logical connection to whether or not we can "save the rich." Therefore, because JFK has established no logical flow between his premise and his conclusion, he commits non sequitur.


3. Explain why a speech that blatantly commits so many fallacies can still be so effective and so famous.
Substance, as important as it is, is not in itself memorable. Rhetoric is memorable. To this end, one can dress up the most fallacious of arguments and make it sound convincing. The Kennedy speech is a brilliant example of this, for when we look below the surface of his words we see that not only are numerous fallacies committed, but that he is hardly arguing for anything. Kennedy demonstrates a brilliant ability to dress up the most hollow of ideas in bombast. This rhetorical mastery is what sticks in the public mind, and this is why speeches like Kennedy's remain so famous to this day.

Monday, January 16, 2012

1/12/12 - "Duck and Cover"

Overt message?
"Duck and cover" - it's repeated multiple times, the video is even named for this idea.

Covert message?
The American government will protect us from harm. Civil defense works and "older people" are shown to be those best trusted. As a whole, the "duck and cover" concept is not really about safety - an atomic bomb blast would probably kill you anyway - but about the illusion of safety and the government being the primary providers of it.

Propaganda or information? Why?
Ducking and covering will not protect anyone from an atomic bomb. The government at the time knew the power of the atomic bomb. The purpose of this video is not to inform, but to provide an illusory idea of possible safety in the face of the nuclear threat, and presents the government as the only body capable of protecting us from this threat. In this way, "Duck and Cover" is clearly propaganda.

1/11/12 - "Destination: Earth"

Overt message?
Oil and competition allow for a better society.

Covert message?
Oil companies should not be questioned because they produce benefits for all.

Why is it propaganda? Specific techniques?
The film is essentially making assertions based on "American values" to convince the viewer that oil companies work for the common man. Never is this stated outright, but the ideas of oil and competition are treated with reverence to butter the audience up for this idea. The film continually uses glittering generalities, characterizing the oil industry as contributing to "freedom" and "standard of living" and "security."