1. How do the Savages view those from The Outside, and how does their culture treat them?
The best way to characterize the Savages' opinion of Outsiders, from the evidence we are given, is that it is a sort of contemptuous apathy. Huxley says that, "The very back of the [guide], as he walked along before them, was hostile, sullenly contemptuous" (117). Here we get, yes, the feelings of just one man, but it seems that this one native's attitudes may speak for the whole - the Savages do view Outsiders poorly, but do not in fact make much of an effort to "view" them at all. They seem to be perfectly content to pretend they're not really there, perhaps from thousands of years of the unwelcome strangers coming and going. Furthermore, only two of the Savages, John and Linda, ever make any attempt to speak to the visitors. Part of this may be because they alone know English, but nevertheless no attempt is made by any of the other Savages to even make contact with the visitors, such that John's "Hullo. Good-morrow" (125) is a welcome surprise.
2. Given the opportunity, how would our society treat John the Savage?
Removing the parts of his character that make him more a part of our culture than the people of Brave New World's society, John would perhaps be treated in much the same way today as he is in Brave New World. John's appeal to the people of London is described by Huxley thus: "All upper-caste London was wild to see this delicious creature who had fallen on his knees before the Director of Hatcheries and Conditioning... had called him... 'my father'" (160). Does not our society act similarly when faced with a character so absurd, so hilariously offensive? The persistence of reality TV alone should prove that it does. Would John be treated in quite the same way, under the guardianship of a single man to "have whichever of [the women] he liked" (162)? Certainly not, for in a perplexing reversal of roles, it is our society which would be more likely to treat The Savage as public property. I would predict that, given such a strange, unique specimen of savagery in ordinary society, some cable network would be on the road to producing an exploitative reality show with his name on it.
3. Why does Helmholtz seem as unable to deal with ideas of mothers and fathers and monogamy as everybody else, despite being "special"?
Helmholtz, being someone we might consider to be outside the influence of society's social norms, is in fact less special once we consider why he is special. "That which had made Helmholtz so uncomfortably aware of being himself and all alone was too much ability" (Huxley 78). Helmholtz's difference is not so much an ability to question the ideas his society takes for granted as a whole, as is the case with Winston Smith in 1984, but an ability at language that pushes him to be more honest with himself in his writing. Helmholtz surmises: "It's not enough for the phrases to be good; what you make with them ought to be good too" (Huxley 81). Helmholtz's rebellion against the norm doesn't take place in forming contrary opinions so much as it does in using his ability to formulate opinions everyone already has. The reason Helmholtz can't fathom the idea of monogamy or of parenting is that he, like everyone else (as Bernard is so keen to remind us very often), has been hypnopaedically trained to think within a certain frame. Even Bernard demonstrates a weakness to this training: "Bernard looked [at John's scar] and then quickly, with a little shudder, averted his gaze. His conditioning had made him not so much pathetic as profoundly squeamish" (Huxley 146). The idea of rebellion can only go so far in a society that controls one's very thought processes - even a little alcohol in one's blood surrogate can only send one so far off track.
Tuesday, November 29, 2011
Sunday, November 20, 2011
First Brave New World Reading Journal
The methods of control of society in Brave New World are quite possibly even more stunningly expansive than those exhibited in Orwell's 1984 (appropriate, perhaps, since Huxley's fictional totalitarians rule the entire world, not just a large section of it.) In Brave New World, we are introduced from the beginning to the sheer power of the world government - they control the manufacture of humanity. No longer must the government tolerate the unpredictable influence of parents (in fact, the idea of parenting is so foreign to these people that one student, upon learning of it for the first time "turned pale at the mere description and was on the point of being sick" (Huxley 49).) From the beginning, the state maintains perfect control over the course of a human's life, even going so far as to have a "Social Predestination Room." People are often born as one of a number of completely identical people known as a "Bokinovsky Group." And a social caste system is reinforced by giving "an Epsilon embryo.. an Epsilon environment as well as an Epsilon heredity" (Huxley 28).
Conflict is reduced primarily by an insistence on a "Social Body" which one is socially forbidden from ever acting contrary towards. Relationships have been reduced to the point of dumb sexual promiscuity, such that meaningful relationships are not only uncommon but frowned upon. Most importantly, the presence of the drug "soma is ubiquitous. So powerful is soma that it seems to have supplanted not only religion and alcohol as a depressant, but free thought and individual reflection as a pastime. As the World Controller of West Europe explains to a group of students in the novel, "Take a holiday from reality whenever you like and come back without so much as a headache or a mythology" (Huxley 66).
Perhaps even more so than in 1984, classifying Brave New World as either a dystopia or a utopia is strictly a matter of perspective. What may appear to us or to some character in the novel as an unlivable situation is quite visibly to most of the characters (and perhaps some of us) a perfectly desirable world. Certainly suffering appears to have been mostly destroyed, regardless of what shady methods were used to do so. Ultimately, I would make this claim: Brave New World is a dystopia, because any developed utopia is eventually revealed to be as much. From my standpoint, the creation of a utopia i9nevitably leads to the destruction of a key part of the human experience. In the case of Brave New World, it is, to Bernard, the ability "to be free to be happy in some other way" (Huxley 101). To Helmholtz Watson, it is that "what you make with [phrases] should be good too" (Huxley 81). In my mind, it is inconceivable that these problems should not arise in every utopia for which we are given significant detail, for if utopia were compatible with human character, it would have already occurred.
Conflict is reduced primarily by an insistence on a "Social Body" which one is socially forbidden from ever acting contrary towards. Relationships have been reduced to the point of dumb sexual promiscuity, such that meaningful relationships are not only uncommon but frowned upon. Most importantly, the presence of the drug "soma is ubiquitous. So powerful is soma that it seems to have supplanted not only religion and alcohol as a depressant, but free thought and individual reflection as a pastime. As the World Controller of West Europe explains to a group of students in the novel, "Take a holiday from reality whenever you like and come back without so much as a headache or a mythology" (Huxley 66).
Perhaps even more so than in 1984, classifying Brave New World as either a dystopia or a utopia is strictly a matter of perspective. What may appear to us or to some character in the novel as an unlivable situation is quite visibly to most of the characters (and perhaps some of us) a perfectly desirable world. Certainly suffering appears to have been mostly destroyed, regardless of what shady methods were used to do so. Ultimately, I would make this claim: Brave New World is a dystopia, because any developed utopia is eventually revealed to be as much. From my standpoint, the creation of a utopia i9nevitably leads to the destruction of a key part of the human experience. In the case of Brave New World, it is, to Bernard, the ability "to be free to be happy in some other way" (Huxley 101). To Helmholtz Watson, it is that "what you make with [phrases] should be good too" (Huxley 81). In my mind, it is inconceivable that these problems should not arise in every utopia for which we are given significant detail, for if utopia were compatible with human character, it would have already occurred.
11/16/11 Ethnography
1. Emic perspective will be useful in any case when an understanding of how the people themselves understand their culture. Etic perspective will yield, with good methods, something closer to an objective explanation of the actions. Neither is really superior to the other, as both are necessary for a full understanding of a culture. Emic perspective should be used to gain useful base information. Etic should be used to analyze the reasons for which the culture began and continues.
2. Realizing that objectivity is impossible decreases the likelihood of faulty methods being used to attempt to hide one's biases. Putting one's biases up front also allows them to be analyzed along with the research itself. Having an informant will undoubtedly yield more and more accurate data, especially when trying to utilize the Emic perspective, thus requiring insider perspective. Being up-front with the subjects fosters respect and trust with them, and in a general sense reflects better on the researcher ethically. It also makes taking the subjects out of context less likely.
Listening Journal 11/14/11 - "Blood on the Scarecrow" by John Mellencamp
1. The song seems to be about a perceived decline in family agriculture in the U.S. Mellencamp is singing about the loss of a legacy that he feels is important to his heritage.
2. The song seems to focus on Farmer vs. Society, and perhaps specifically Farmer vs. Corporations. The second verse seems very confrontational, describing Mellencamp's reaction to having to sell his land. He seems almost to vilify those he deems responsible for the situation.
3. Mellencamp uses the scarecrow as a symbol of classic American agricultural culture.
4. Mellencamp repeats usage of "rain" and "blood" because they both tend to have a negative connotation.
5. Mellencamp seems to favor farmers in this song. The first verse talks very sentimentally of farm life, images such as "my grandpa held my hand." In the second verse, he condemns the farm auctioneer, saying "calling it your job ol' hoss sure don't make it right." Mellencamp thus clearly demonstrates what side of the conflict he;s taking.
2. The song seems to focus on Farmer vs. Society, and perhaps specifically Farmer vs. Corporations. The second verse seems very confrontational, describing Mellencamp's reaction to having to sell his land. He seems almost to vilify those he deems responsible for the situation.
3. Mellencamp uses the scarecrow as a symbol of classic American agricultural culture.
4. Mellencamp repeats usage of "rain" and "blood" because they both tend to have a negative connotation.
5. Mellencamp seems to favor farmers in this song. The first verse talks very sentimentally of farm life, images such as "my grandpa held my hand." In the second verse, he condemns the farm auctioneer, saying "calling it your job ol' hoss sure don't make it right." Mellencamp thus clearly demonstrates what side of the conflict he;s taking.
Sunday, November 13, 2011
Reading Response Journal 11/11/11 - Othering
1. The West views the East, paradoxically as a place of inferiority - a reflection of the worst aspects of itself -and as a place of exotic and strange customs.
2. When the excerpt says the West views the East "homogeneously" it means that westerners tend to have trouble thinking of "Orientals" as individuals rather than a group. They homogenize Orientals in that they assume them to be the same throughout.
3. The excerpt says Westerners view Easterners as making their decisions based on tradition, rather than individual factors. Similarly, their reactions and emotions are viewed as part of Eastern character, and not as related to the many roles each individual plays in life and the immutable attributes of each individual.
4. This view of dehumanizing non-Westerners has been used to morally justify colonialism. It is easier to subjugate and enslave somebody when they're simply "Oriental" rather than a human being. Furthermore, creating a common enemy allows a degree of allegiance and unity across groups in the West.
5. Yes, this view of the East is still very prominent. Even if people today are wary of words like "Oriental," they still characterize foreign people - specifically non-Whites - as members of a group rather than individual human beings. See American attitudes towards Muslims, especially over the last ten years, for evidence of this.
2. When the excerpt says the West views the East "homogeneously" it means that westerners tend to have trouble thinking of "Orientals" as individuals rather than a group. They homogenize Orientals in that they assume them to be the same throughout.
3. The excerpt says Westerners view Easterners as making their decisions based on tradition, rather than individual factors. Similarly, their reactions and emotions are viewed as part of Eastern character, and not as related to the many roles each individual plays in life and the immutable attributes of each individual.
4. This view of dehumanizing non-Westerners has been used to morally justify colonialism. It is easier to subjugate and enslave somebody when they're simply "Oriental" rather than a human being. Furthermore, creating a common enemy allows a degree of allegiance and unity across groups in the West.
5. Yes, this view of the East is still very prominent. Even if people today are wary of words like "Oriental," they still characterize foreign people - specifically non-Whites - as members of a group rather than individual human beings. See American attitudes towards Muslims, especially over the last ten years, for evidence of this.
Sunday, November 6, 2011
Final 1984 Reading Journal
The answers to 1984's ending lies in an understanding of what George Orwell wanted to accomplish with this book. The title provides the most obvious hint - 1984, a year in the future. Orwell is not trying to discuss modern day politics, nor is he necessarily even discussing the results of real life developments that are taking place (the book claims that the Americans invaded Britain in 1945. Orwell wrote 1984 in 1949, thus making clear that he wrote the book as a sort of progressed alternate history.) Thus it seems that Orwell's primary purpose in writing 1984 is as a warning.
It is for this reason that Big Brother is the final victor. Orwell's goal is not to set out a plan to overthrow an already-existing government that resembles that of the Party. O'Brien in fact seems to serve as an author avatar in some cases, as he explains the plan set forth in the book "is nonsense. The secret accumulation of knowledge - a gradual spread of enlightenment - ultimately a proletarian rebellion - the overthrow of the Party... It is all nonsense" (215). O'Brien is Orwell's tool for delivering the harsh realities of the reality crafted in his book, and as a result we are hardly in a position to argue that he is wrong. Possibly both Orwell and O'Brien underestimate the power of the proletarians, and perhaps some day a gradual enlightenment will occur. But the two O's are probably right - the hope of proletarian rebellion is virtually nonexistent. So long as they are ignorant they will never rebel, and until they rebel, they will always be ignorant. The Party has institutionalized one of humanities oldest catch-22's.
Winston's fate is left somewhat open, but we can take hints from the final chapter of book three. While sitting in the Chestnut Tree Cafe, Winston hears a song over the telescreen:
It is for this reason that Big Brother is the final victor. Orwell's goal is not to set out a plan to overthrow an already-existing government that resembles that of the Party. O'Brien in fact seems to serve as an author avatar in some cases, as he explains the plan set forth in the book "is nonsense. The secret accumulation of knowledge - a gradual spread of enlightenment - ultimately a proletarian rebellion - the overthrow of the Party... It is all nonsense" (215). O'Brien is Orwell's tool for delivering the harsh realities of the reality crafted in his book, and as a result we are hardly in a position to argue that he is wrong. Possibly both Orwell and O'Brien underestimate the power of the proletarians, and perhaps some day a gradual enlightenment will occur. But the two O's are probably right - the hope of proletarian rebellion is virtually nonexistent. So long as they are ignorant they will never rebel, and until they rebel, they will always be ignorant. The Party has institutionalized one of humanities oldest catch-22's.
Winston's fate is left somewhat open, but we can take hints from the final chapter of book three. While sitting in the Chestnut Tree Cafe, Winston hears a song over the telescreen:
Under the spreading chestnut tree/ I sold you and you sold me- (241)The verse recalls a memory Winston has of seeing the three traitors whom he knows were innocent - Jones, Aaronson, and Rutherford - at the same cafe he now sits in every day. Just as "Rutherford's ruinous face" had "eyes [that] were full of tears," (66) Winston cries when he hears the song. The implication is thus that Winston will face Jones, Aaronson, and Rutherford's fate - he will be rearrested on (this time) phony charges. However, given that Winston's treasons were less publicized than Jones, Aaronson, and Rutherford's, he will probably not be given a public trial and execution. Indeed, the final paragraphs of the book's ultimate chapter seem to indicate Winston dies just as he had anticipated - an unseen bullet through the back of the head, somewhere in the halls of the Ministry of Love. What these last paragraphs truly mean is open to interpretation, as they appear to occur outside of the normal flow of events. However, assuming they are not some sort of hallucination, this explanation seems to make the best sense of the given information.
Viewing Journal 11/3/11 - "Love Language"
1. At first I assumed that the girl was just being coy or playing hard-to-get. This was based on an assumption that she could hear the boy, which evidently turned out to be incorrect. Later on I did start following what the filmmaker was trying to do, and initially assumed the girl was mute. It didn't occur to me until the end that she was deaf.
2. I believe that this is not a cultural conflict. The issue here is in the question of whether any cultures are being represented, and I don't think they are. Neither the ability nor the inability to hear are cultural attributes - they're strictly biological, whereas culture has been established in this class to be learned behavior. The man assumes that the girl has hearing, but making that assumption doesn't seem cultural as much as generically trained behavior. Most people, if raised around few or no deaf individuals, will tend to assume others have the ability. There's nothing cultural about this - it's a natural development for most humans. Even if one argues that either hearing or non-hearing is a culture, describing this as a cultural conflict diminishes the role of individual traits. There is no reason to believe that refusal to share one's deafness is a trait ubiquitous or even common in the deaf community. Most likely, this girl is shy by nature. One's nature tends to be a combination of biological and early emotional factors, and thus it's not really appropriate to call this a culture of any sort.
3. The main external conflict here is between the boy and the girl, as the former wants to be conversational, while the latter refuses.
4. The most obvious internal conflict here is the girl's conflict between wanting to talk to the boy and her embarrassment over her disability.
5. Eventually, the girl warms up to the boy and tells him of her deafness, thus resolving both her internal conflict (her desires win) and the external conflict (the boy wins).
2. I believe that this is not a cultural conflict. The issue here is in the question of whether any cultures are being represented, and I don't think they are. Neither the ability nor the inability to hear are cultural attributes - they're strictly biological, whereas culture has been established in this class to be learned behavior. The man assumes that the girl has hearing, but making that assumption doesn't seem cultural as much as generically trained behavior. Most people, if raised around few or no deaf individuals, will tend to assume others have the ability. There's nothing cultural about this - it's a natural development for most humans. Even if one argues that either hearing or non-hearing is a culture, describing this as a cultural conflict diminishes the role of individual traits. There is no reason to believe that refusal to share one's deafness is a trait ubiquitous or even common in the deaf community. Most likely, this girl is shy by nature. One's nature tends to be a combination of biological and early emotional factors, and thus it's not really appropriate to call this a culture of any sort.
3. The main external conflict here is between the boy and the girl, as the former wants to be conversational, while the latter refuses.
4. The most obvious internal conflict here is the girl's conflict between wanting to talk to the boy and her embarrassment over her disability.
5. Eventually, the girl warms up to the boy and tells him of her deafness, thus resolving both her internal conflict (her desires win) and the external conflict (the boy wins).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)